C corp vs. LLC vs. S corp

Business basics4min read

An LLC is a legal entity; C corp and S corp describe federal tax treatment. C corporations pay entity-level income tax. LLCs default to pass-through taxation; S corporations also pass income through, but restrict eligible owners and allow only one economic class of stock.

DifferenceC corpLLC, default tax treatmentS corp
What it isA corporation taxed under Subchapter CA state-law limited liability companyA corporation or eligible LLC with an S tax election
Federal income taxCorporation pays tax; shareholders pay tax on dividendsSingle-member LLC is usually disregarded; multi-member LLC is usually taxed as a partnershipIncome generally passes through to shareholders
Ownership restrictionsNo S-style federal shareholder restrictionsNo S-style federal shareholder restrictionsMaximum 100 shareholders, with eligibility restrictions
Equity structureMultiple stock classes permittedFlexible membership interests, subject to the operating agreement and tax rulesOne economic class of stock; voting rights can differ
Institutional venture capitalStandard structureOften unsuitable for a fund's tax requirementsOwnership and stock-class restrictions usually prevent it

This comparison uses US federal tax rules. State taxes and filing requirements differ. All three structures can provide limited liability under state law, but none erases a personal guarantee or protects you from your own misconduct.

Distributing $100,000 of business profit

Each business has $100,000 of taxable profit and distributes all available after-tax cash to one US individual owner.

For illustration, use a 24% ordinary-income tax rate and a 15% qualified-dividend rate. The federal C corporation tax rate is 21%. Exclude state taxes, employment taxes, net investment income tax and the qualified business income deduction.

CalculationC corpDefault LLCS corp
Business profit$100,000$100,000$100,000
Entity-level federal income tax$100,000 × 21% = $21,000$0$0
Cash available for distribution$79,000$100,000$100,000
Owner's federal income tax$79,000 × 15% = $11,850$100,000 × 24% = $24,000$100,000 × 24% = $24,000
Cash remaining for owner$67,150$76,000$76,000

This isolates income-tax layers, not total tax for a working owner. An S corporation cannot replace reasonable compensation for services with distributions.

The result changes if profits stay in the business. The C corporation retains $79,000 after corporate tax, without an immediate dividend tax. LLC members and S corporation shareholders generally owe tax on allocated income even when no cash is distributed. That is why pass-through owners should address tax distributions in their agreements.

When each structure fits

C corp: a startup seeking institutional venture capital

A C corporation supports preferred stock and the ownership structures venture funds need. An S corporation cannot have a partnership or corporation as a shareholder, which blocks many venture funds. Its single-class restriction also conflicts with preferred equity economics.

For a founder planning a conventional venture round, investor compatibility usually matters more than minimizing this year's tax on distributed profits. A startup that reinvests its cash might not pay dividends at all.

LLC: an owner-run business with flexible economics

An LLC often fits a business whose owners expect to distribute profits, negotiate different economic interests or keep ownership closely held.

The flexibility comes with tax complexity. Partnership allocations must satisfy tax rules, and members can receive taxable income without matching cash. Some angels invest in LLCs; many venture funds avoid pass-through tax exposure and reporting.

S corp: an eligible business with working owners

S status can fit a profitable, closely held business whose owners qualify. Eligible shareholders include US citizens and resident individuals, plus certain trusts, estates and exempt organizations. Nonresident alien shareholders are prohibited.

The IRS requires reasonable compensation for shareholder services before non-wage distributions. Do not accept "S corps save tax" as a complete recommendation. Ask for a projection that includes salary, payroll taxes, state taxes and extra administration.

What the paperwork actually says

IRS Form 2553 elects S corporation tax treatment. Its shareholder-consent section records shareholders' agreement to the election. It does not create a corporation under state law.

An LLC's operating agreement governs ownership and distributions. A corporation's charter and stock documents establish its share rights. These documents matter separately from the tax election.

Before admitting a new S corporation shareholder or changing economic rights, check eligibility. A prohibited shareholder or second class of stock can terminate S status.

Questions people ask

Can an LLC be taxed as an S corp or C corp?

Yes. An eligible LLC can elect corporate taxation and, if it meets the requirements, S corporation treatment. Its state-law entity remains an LLC. Changing tax treatment does not automatically turn membership interests into corporate stock for fundraising purposes.

Does an S corp eliminate self-employment taxes?

It does not eliminate employment taxes on compensation. Wages paid to a working shareholder are subject to payroll taxes. S corporation pass-through income generally is not self-employment income, but paying an artificially low salary to increase distributions invites IRS scrutiny.

Can I start as an LLC and convert before fundraising?

Yes, but conversion requires legal and tax planning. Existing debt, asset values, ownership terms and prior tax elections can affect the result. If institutional funding is the near-term plan, compare the cost of starting with a corporation against a later conversion.

Related terms

Sources

  1. Internal Revenue Service, "Limited Liability Company (LLC)."
  2. Internal Revenue Service, "S corporations."
  3. Internal Revenue Service, "S corporation compensation and medical insurance issues."
  4. Internal Revenue Service, "Instructions for Form 2553."
  5. Internal Revenue Service, Publication 542, "Corporations."