Private credit vs. private equity

Raising money4min read

Private credit is privately negotiated lending by nonbank investors. Private equity is investment in ownership of private companies. Credit creates repayment obligations; equity gives investors a share of the company's future value and may give them control.

DifferencePrivate creditPrivate equity
What the investor providesA loanCapital in exchange for shares
How the investor earns moneyInterest, fees and sometimes equity participationDividends and proceeds from selling shares
RepaymentPrincipal and interest are due under the loan agreementNo ordinary loan repayment schedule
OwnershipA loan alone does not dilute shareholdersExisting shareholders' percentage falls when new shares are issued
ControlCovenants restrict certain decisions; default gives lenders remediesBoard seats, consent rights or majority ownership
Position if the business failsCreditors rank ahead of shareholdersShareholders receive what remains after creditors
Main risk for the business ownerDebt payments and refinancing pressureGiving up future proceeds and decision-making power

In fund-industry usage, "private equity" often means buyout or growth-equity investing. Venture capital also involves ownership in private companies, but investors usually discuss it as a separate category.

Raising $2 million: repayment versus 20% ownership

An owner holds all the shares in a business that needs $2 million. An equity investor offers that amount for 20%, implying an $8 million pre-money valuation and a $10 million post-money valuation.

Alternatively, a lender offers $2 million at 10% interest for one year, with principal and interest payable at year-end. The business sells then for $20 million.

The rate and maturity are illustrative, not market benchmarks. There are no fees, warrants, taxes, other debt, surplus cash or preferential equity payouts.

CalculationPrivate creditPrivate equity
Capital raised$2,000,000$2,000,000
Founder's ownership afterward100%80%
Interest due$2,000,000 × 10% = $200,000$0
Investor receives at sale$2,000,000 principal + $200,000 interest$20,000,000 × 20% = $4,000,000
Founder receives at sale$20,000,000 − $2,200,000 = $17,800,000$20,000,000 × 80% = $16,000,000

Debt leaves the founder with $1.8 million more in this outcome. But the result reverses at a lower sale value: at $6 million, the founder receives $3.8 million with debt versus $4.8 million with equity.

The harder difference appears if no sale happens. The loan still comes due. The equity investor cannot demand loan repayment merely because the expected exit did not arrive.

When each fits

Private credit: a credible repayment source

Private credit fits businesses with operating cash flow, assets or another repayment source a lender accepts. It preserves ownership, but interest, covenants and maturity still bind when growth disappoints.

Private equity: room to accept ownership risk

Equity fits businesses that need capital without scheduled debt payments, and owners willing to share future proceeds and control.

Check where the money goes. Newly issued shares fund the company; a secondary share purchase pays the selling shareholders. A private-equity transaction can contain both.

For pre-seed through Series A companies with little dependable cash flow, venture capital is usually the relevant equity category. Some venture-backed startups qualify for venture debt, but that remains a repayment obligation.

What the documents change

The NVCA Model Term Sheet covers liquidation preferences, board composition and investor consent rights. These provisions can change a founder's proceeds and freedom to act even when an investor owns a minority stake.

The example above uses simple pro rata ownership. Preferred shares can produce a different split, especially at a low sale price. Model the actual preference terms before treating "20% ownership" as "20% of every exit."

On the credit side, read the loan agreement's interest, maturity, collateral, covenant and default provisions together. A covenant breach can trigger remedies before the scheduled repayment date.

Compare total borrowing cost, including fees and any warrants, rather than the headline interest rate alone. Question personal guarantees and financial covenant tests the business cannot reliably meet. For equity, question a valuation discussion that leaves liquidation preferences or control rights unexplained.

Questions people ask

Is private credit safer than private equity?

For investors, creditors rank ahead of shareholders in a liquidation. That improves their position but does not guarantee repayment. Recovery depends on business value, collateral and priority among lenders. For the business owner, debt can create greater immediate risk because missed payments can trigger default.

Does private credit dilute ownership?

A loan alone does not. A financing package that includes warrants or a separate equity investment can dilute existing shareholders. Check the entire package rather than treating the label "private credit" as a promise of no dilution.

Can the same investment firm offer both?

Yes. An asset manager can operate private-credit and private-equity funds, and a transaction can combine debt with equity. The firm's name does not determine your obligations. The loan agreement, share terms and other transaction documents do.

Related terms

Sources

  1. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Investor.gov, "Private Equity Funds".
  2. National Venture Capital Association, Model Legal Documents, "Term Sheet".