Regulation A vs. Regulation D

Also called Reg A vs. Reg D.

Raising money4min read

Regulation A permits public fundraising from retail investors after SEC qualification. Regulation D provides exemptions used for private fundraising, usually from accredited investors. Reg A brings more filing and reporting work; Rule 506 under Reg D fits most angel and VC rounds.

The main differences

Both are exemptions from SEC registration under US securities law. Reg A still requires SEC qualification of an offering statement before sales. Reg D includes several exemptions, with different rules.

IssueRegulation ARegulation D, focusing on Rule 506
Maximum raiseTier 1: $20 million; Tier 2: $75 million, each over 12 monthsNo dollar limit under Rule 506
Who can investAccredited and non-accredited investors; Tier 2 limits certain non-accredited purchases506(b): accredited investors plus up to 35 qualifying non-accredited purchasers per 90-calendar-day period. 506(c): accredited purchasers only
Public advertisingPermitted, subject to offering rulesProhibited under 506(b); permitted under 506(c)
SEC processFile Form 1-A and obtain qualification before salesFile Form D, generally within 15 days after the first sale; no SEC qualification
Financial statements and reportingTier 2 requires audited financials and annual, semiannual and certain current reportsReg D itself imposes no periodic reporting regime; disclosure duties increase when 506(b) includes non-accredited purchasers
State securities registrationTier 1 remains subject to state review; Tier 2 preempts state registrationRule 506 preempts state registration, but notice filings and fees can remain

Reg D also includes Rule 504, which permits up to $10 million over 12 months. It has different solicitation and state-law requirements. Do not treat every Reg D offering as a Rule 506 offering.

SEC qualification is not an endorsement of the company or its investment merits.

Raising $5 million through either route

A startup has a $20 million pre-money valuation and raises $5 million of newly issued equity. The founder owns all existing shares. There are no SAFEs, notes, option-pool changes or other shareholders, and the share rights are identical.

Compare a Tier 2 Reg A offering with a Rule 506(c) offering:

ItemReg A Tier 2Reg D Rule 506(c)
Investors1,000 eligible retail investors20 verified accredited investors
Investment per investor$5,000$250,000
Gross proceeds1,000 × $5,000 = $5 million20 × $250,000 = $5 million
Post-money valuation$20 million + $5 million = $25 million$20 million + $5 million = $25 million
New investors' ownership$5 million ÷ $25 million = 20%$5 million ÷ $25 million = 20%
Founder's remaining ownership80%80%

All Reg A buyers in this illustration satisfy the applicable investment limits.

The exemption does not determine dilution. Price and share terms do. The founder gives up 20% either way, but managing 1,000 direct holders creates a different administrative burden from managing 20.

These are gross proceeds. Offering expenses reduce cash available to the business without automatically changing the ownership percentages.

What the filings say

Form 1-A contains the Reg A offering circular: the business, risks, financial statements and offering terms. Investors receive an offering circular, and the SEC must qualify the offering statement before securities are sold.

Form D is a notice of an exempt offering. It identifies the exemption claimed and information about the issuer and financing. It is not an SEC-reviewed offering circular or evidence of SEC approval.

The subscription documents matter too. In a 506(c) offering, purchasers must be accredited and the issuer must take reasonable steps to verify that status. Calling an offering "Reg D" does not establish that those requirements were met.

When each route fits

Choose Rule 506(b) when you are raising privately from angels or VC funds without public advertising. Its allowance for non-accredited investors comes with sophistication and disclosure requirements, so including friends or family is not a paperwork shortcut.

Choose Rule 506(c) when public promotion matters and every purchaser will be accredited. Build verification into the subscription process before accepting investments.

Consider Reg A when access to retail investors is central to the financing plan, particularly if the company already has an audience that wants to invest. Budget for qualification, disclosure preparation and, under Tier 2, ongoing reporting.

For a conventional pre-seed to Series A round, Reg A's wider investor access rarely justifies the extra process on its own.

Questions people ask

Can non-accredited investors invest under both?

Yes, but the rules differ. Reg A permits retail participation. In Tier 2, a non-accredited individual's purchase is capped at 10% of the greater of annual income or net worth, unless the securities will be exchange-listed. Rule 506(b) permits limited non-accredited participation with sophistication requirements; 506(c) permits none.

Is a Reg A offering an IPO?

Not necessarily. "Mini-IPO" is an informal nickname, not a promise of exchange listing. A company can complete a Reg A offering without listing its shares on a stock exchange.

Can investors sell their shares immediately?

Reg A shares are not restricted solely because they were issued under Reg A, but a buyer and trading venue may not exist. Reg D securities are restricted securities: resale requires registration or an available exemption. Neither route guarantees liquidity.

Related terms

Sources

  1. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Regulation A, 17 CFR §§ 230.251-230.263.
  2. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Regulation D, 17 CFR §§ 230.501-230.508.
  3. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Form 1-A, "Regulation A Offering Statement."
  4. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Form D, "Notice of Exempt Offering of Securities."