SAFE vs. convertible note

Raising money4min read

A standard YC SAFE is not debt: it has no interest or maturity date. A convertible note is a loan with interest and a maturity date. Both can convert into startup shares, but identical valuation caps need not buy identical ownership.

This comparison uses US practice and YC's post-money valuation-cap SAFE unless stated otherwise.

FeatureSAFEConvertible note
Legal structureContract for future equity or specified event payoutsDebt that can convert into equity
InterestNone in the standard YC formAccrues at the negotiated rate
Maturity dateNoneA contractual deadline for repayment or other treatment
Conversion triggerAn equity financing under the form's termsUsually a "qualified financing" that meets a minimum raise
Valuation capPost-money in this YC formOften pre-money; the document's definition controls
Shutdown claimBehind creditors, ahead of common shareholdersDebt claim; ranking depends on security and subordination
Main founder riskSelling more ownership than expected across multiple SAFEsA repayment deadline arriving before the company has cash

The same $8M cap produces different ownership

Two companies each receive $1M. One issues a SAFE with an $8M post-money cap. The other issues a note with an $8M pre-money cap and 8% simple annual interest.

Both convert after 12 months. All note interest converts at the cap price. There are no other securities, discounts or option-pool changes. These are illustrative terms, not market averages.

Each company then raises $4M at a $16M pre-money valuation that includes the converting securities. Both caps produce a lower conversion price than the new round's share price.

The SAFE investor's ownership before the new cash is:

$1M ÷ $8M = 12.5%

The note accrues $1M × 8% × 1 year = $80,000 of interest. Its pre-money cap excludes the note itself, so its investor's ownership before the new cash is:

$1.08M ÷ ($8M + $1.08M) = 11.89%

The new investors buy $4M ÷ ($16M + $4M) = 20%. Everyone already on the cap table retains 80% of their previous stake.

Ownership after the roundSAFE companyNote company
Original shareholders70.00%70.48%
SAFE or note investor10.00%9.52%
New investors20.00%20.00%

Here, the SAFE costs the original shareholders slightly more ownership despite the note's interest. The different cap definitions explain the result. This is not a rule that SAFEs always dilute founders more.

Comparing only the dollar amount of the cap misses the economics. You need its capitalization definition, the treatment of interest and the next round's option-pool assumptions.

When each one fits

A SAFE fits an early-stage company that needs equity funding but cannot support a repayment obligation. Removing interest and maturity also removes two subjects of negotiation. The trade-off is that founders must track ownership sold across every SAFE, not treat the cash as dilution-free until conversion.

A convertible note fits a deal where debt protections are part of the bargain. An investor might require interest, a maturity date or creditor priority. A defined bridge to an expected financing can use a note, but calling something a bridge does not make repayment affordable.

For founders, the key question is not which instrument sounds simpler. It is whether the company can live with the obligations if the next round never happens.

What the documents change

YC's post-money valuation-cap SAFE includes converting securities in its definition of "Company Capitalization." Its equity-financing provision compares conversion outcomes and gives the holder the one that produces more shares. The form also has separate payout rules for a sale or dissolution.

A note requires close reading of different clauses:

  • Qualified financing: How much new cash triggers automatic conversion?
  • Conversion price: Does accrued interest receive the same cap or discount as principal?
  • Maturity: Is repayment due, is conversion available, or must holders approve an extension?
  • Amendments: Can a majority approve changes, or can one small holder block them?

Question a maturity date that your cash plan cannot support. Security over company assets also changes the risk materially compared with an unsecured note. For either instrument, model any pro rata side letter separately: conversion ownership and the right to buy more shares are different things.

Before the next round, incoming investors will need the signed instruments, side letters and a cap table that reconciles their conversion math.

Questions people ask

What happens if the company never raises a priced round?

A standard YC SAFE has no deadline that forces repayment merely because time passes. It can remain outstanding until a contractual event occurs. A note reaches maturity, when its repayment, conversion or extension provisions matter. Neither instrument guarantees that the investor will recover money if the business fails.

Can both instruments have a valuation cap and a discount?

Yes, depending on the form. Where both apply, the conversion formula usually gives the investor the lower share price rather than stacking both benefits. YC's current US post-money forms offer separate valuation-cap-only and discount-only versions, so do not assume every SAFE contains both.

Related terms

Sources

  1. Y Combinator, "Safe Financing Documents," US post-money valuation-cap form.
  2. Y Combinator, "Post-Money Safe User Guide."
  3. US Securities and Exchange Commission, "Investor Bulletin: Be Cautious of SAFEs in Crowdfunding."