Down round

Also called down-round financing.

Deals and equity8min read

A down round is an equity financing in which a company sells shares at a lower price per share than in its previous priced round. It often comes with a lower valuation and can increase dilution for founders and employees.

Key takeaways

  • Compare price per share, not just headline valuations. Adjust for stock splits and check how each financing defines the share count.
  • Issuing new shares dilutes existing holders. Anti-dilution protection for preferred investors can shift more of that dilution onto founders and employees.
  • Broad-based weighted-average protection considers both the lower price and the amount raised. Full-ratchet protection resets the protected conversion price regardless of the amount raised.
  • Ownership percentage is only part of the cost. Liquidation preferences, option-pool increases and new control rights can matter just as much.
  • A down round can be the right decision if it funds a credible operating plan on better terms than the available alternatives.

How a down round works

In a priced equity round, investors exchange cash for shares at an agreed price. A down round sets that price below the previous round's price.

The company receives the new investment. Existing shareholders do not have to sell their shares or receive cash. Instead, their percentage ownership falls as the company issues more stock.

For a US venture-backed startup, there is often another step: earlier preferred investors have price-based anti-dilution protection. A qualifying lower-priced issuance reduces their preferred stock's conversion price. Their preferred shares then convert into more common shares than before.

That protection does not belong to everyone. Founders' common stock and employee options do not automatically receive it.

The comparison also needs care. A previous post-money valuation and a proposed pre-money valuation are not directly interchangeable. Option-pool changes and outstanding convertible securities affect the share count. Ask for the price per share and the fully diluted capitalization used to calculate it.

A sale of existing shares between shareholders at a lower price is a secondary transaction, not itself a new funding round.

How a $4M down round changes ownership

A startup has the following capitalization before its new financing:

  • Founders and employees hold 6 million common shares.
  • Earlier investors hold 4 million preferred shares, purchased for $2 each, for an $8 million investment.
  • Those preferred shares initially convert into common stock one-for-one.

The company now raises $4 million at $1 per share and issues 4 million new preferred shares, also initially convertible one-for-one.

The illustration has no SAFEs, notes, warrants or unissued option reserves. The new price is fixed at $1; only the earlier preferred series receives the anti-dilution adjustments shown below. All ownership figures count preferred shares as converted into common stock.

MeasureBefore financingNo anti-dilution adjustmentBroad-based weighted averageFull ratchet
Earlier investors' shares, as converted4M4M4.667M8M
Total shares, as converted10M14M14.667M18M
Founders and employees60.0%42.9%40.9%33.3%
Earlier investors40.0%28.6%31.8%44.4%
New investors0%28.6%27.3%22.2%

Figures are rounded.

No anti-dilution adjustment

The arithmetic is simply:

6M founder and employee shares ÷ 14M total shares = 42.9%

The lower price means the company must sell more shares to raise the same cash than it would at a higher price.

Broad-based weighted-average protection

The NVCA model Certificate of Incorporation uses a formula with this structure:

New conversion price = old conversion price × (A + B) ÷ (A + C)

For this example:

  • A is the 10 million shares outstanding before the financing, counted under the provision's capitalization definition.
  • B is the number of shares the new money would have bought at the old conversion price: $4M ÷ $2 = 2 million.
  • C is the number actually issued: $4M ÷ $1 = 4 million.

Therefore:

New conversion price = $2 × (10M + 2M) ÷ (10M + 4M) = approximately $1.714286.

The earlier investors' 4 million preferred shares now convert into:

4M × ($2 ÷ $1.714286) = approximately 4.667 million common shares

This cushions their dilution without preserving their original 40% ownership. The additional common-equivalent shares also reduce the new investors' percentage, which is why everyone should agree on the pro forma cap table before signing.

Full-ratchet protection

Full ratchet resets the earlier conversion price from $2 to $1 for this qualifying issuance.

The earlier preferred shares therefore convert into:

4M × ($2 ÷ $1) = 8 million common shares

The founders and employees end up with 6M ÷ 18M = 33.3%. Unlike weighted-average protection, full ratchet does not soften the adjustment because the lower-priced financing is small.

In a real transaction, establish whether the negotiated valuation or the price per share stays fixed when these adjustments are included. That choice changes the calculation.

Why the exit payout can be worse than the ownership table suggests

Suppose the new $4 million investment receives a senior 1x non-participating liquidation preference. The earlier investors retain an $8 million preference behind it.

At a $10 million sale, with no debt or transaction costs and both series taking their preferences:

RecipientProceeds
New investors$4M
Earlier investors$6M
Founders and employees holding common stock$0

The earlier investors cannot collect their full $8 million preference because only $6 million remains.

This is why a founder should request an exit waterfall as well as an ownership table. A meaningful common-stock percentage does not guarantee proceeds at a modest sale price.

What the documents say

The NVCA model Certificate of Incorporation describes price-based anti-dilution through adjustments to a preferred series' conversion price. Its weighted-average provision defines the capitalization included in the formula and the issuances excluded from it, such as specified employee equity issuances.

The operative question is not simply whether the company calls the financing a down round. It is whether the issuance triggers a particular series' contractual protection.

Different preferred series can have different conversion prices and rights. A financing can trigger protection for one series but not another.

The NVCA model term sheet summarizes economic terms, but the final charter contains the operative preferred-stock provisions. Read the actual formula, exceptions and waiver requirements. A term sheet's brief reference to weighted-average protection is not enough to reproduce the cap table.

Terms worth questioning

There is no single acceptable valuation cut. Judge the full package against the cash the business needs and the alternatives available.

  • Full-ratchet protection. Ask why the amount raised should have no effect on the adjustment. Model it beside broad-based weighted-average protection, rather than accepting the label without calculating its cost.
  • Senior or participating preferences. Seniority changes who gets paid first. Participating preferred can receive its preference and then share in the remaining proceeds. Model both features at several exit values.
  • A larger option pool. A pre-money pool increase adds dilution for existing holders before the new investment. Tie the requested pool to a hiring plan, not an unexplained target.
  • Pay-to-play provisions. These can penalize existing investors who do not participate, including through conversion of their preferred stock into common stock. Check who must invest, how much and what rights they lose.
  • Insider-led terms. If existing investors set the price and receive favorable new rights, board conflicts need careful handling. Document the alternatives considered and get advice on approvals and process.

For a Delaware corporation, charter amendments and preferred-stock rights implicate Delaware corporate law as well as the existing financing documents. Do not assume either that every investor must agree or that a board vote alone is sufficient.

Before circulating a proposal, prepare the current cap table, proposed post-financing cap table, anti-dilution calculations and exit waterfall. Prospective investors and counsel also need the current charter and relevant financing agreements to verify the rights already outstanding.

Down round versus dilution

TermWhat it describesWhat it does not establish
Down roundNew financing at a lower comparable price per shareHow much ownership founders lose or what they receive at exit
Flat roundNew financing at the same comparable price per shareThat existing shareholders avoid dilution
DilutionA reduction in an existing holder's percentage ownershipWhether the company's valuation rose or fell

An up round can dilute founders too. The difference is how many shares the company must sell for the cash raised, plus any contractual adjustments.

Questions founders ask

What does a down round mean?

It means new equity investors are paying less per comparable share than investors paid in the previous priced round. It does not, by itself, mean the company is insolvent. A changed market, missed milestones or an earlier overvaluation can all lead to a lower financing price.

What is down round financing?

It is new capital raised through a lower-priced equity round. The company gets the investment proceeds and issues new shares. Earlier shareholders usually keep their shares, but their ownership percentages and preferred-stock conversion rights can change.

Can a SAFE financing be a down round?

A lower SAFE valuation cap is not the same as a lower priced-round share price. People sometimes describe it informally as a down round. When SAFEs convert in a later equity financing, include their conversion shares in the model and apply the actual documents rather than comparing caps alone.

Do existing investors have to agree to a down round?

Some approvals may be required under the charter, investor agreements and applicable law. Preferred investors may have consent rights over new securities or charter changes. Anti-dilution protection can sometimes be waived with specified holder approval, but the required vote comes from the documents, not a universal rule.

What happens to employee stock options?

A lower preferred-stock financing price does not automatically change an option's exercise price. If the underlying common stock is worth less than that exercise price, the option is underwater. Any repricing or replacement is a separate decision that needs corporate and tax review.

Related terms

Sources

  1. National Venture Capital Association, Model Legal Documents, "Certificate of Incorporation."
  2. National Venture Capital Association, Model Legal Documents, "Term Sheet."
  3. State of Delaware, Delaware General Corporation Law, Sections 151 and 242.