Legal opinion
Also called an opinion letter or closing opinion in transactions.
A legal opinion is a lawyer's reasoned conclusion about a legal question, based on stated facts and law. In business transactions, it often takes the form of a letter covering specific issues, not a guarantee that the deal is safe.
The term also refers to a court's written explanation of its decision.
How it works
A transactional opinion identifies who may rely on it, the law covered, assumptions and qualifications. In startup financing, it might address the company's legal existence, authority to sign the financing documents and valid issuance of shares.
Read those limits carefully. An opinion on valid share issuance says nothing about whether the company will succeed.
A $2 million round with an opinion condition
In this illustrative seed financing, the purchase agreement makes delivery of an agreed counsel opinion a condition to the investor's funding.
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| New shares | 1,000,000 |
| Price per share | $2 |
| Investment | 1,000,000 × $2 = $2,000,000 |
If the required opinion is missing, the investor need not fund unless it waives the condition. The opinion does not establish that $2 is a fair price.
What the document says
The NVCA model Stock Purchase Agreement includes an optional closing condition for an opinion from company counsel. If included in the signed agreement, delivery becomes part of what the company must provide to close.
Agree the scope early. Question a request for an unqualified assurance that the company complies with every law.
Check the letter's disclosure and reliance limits before sharing it with investors. Permission to read an opinion is not necessarily permission to rely on it.
Questions people ask
What does a legal opinion mean?
In a transaction, it states counsel's conclusions on defined legal issues. It is not a court ruling, and a court need not agree with it.
