Most-favored-nation clause

Also called an MFN clause.

Deals and equity4min read

A most-favored-nation (MFN) clause is a contract provision that gives one party the right to terms at least as favorable as those offered to specified others. It can cover prices, fees or investment terms, depending on the contract.

International trade also uses "most-favored-nation" for nondiscrimination between trading partners. That treaty concept is separate from a private contract clause.

Key takeaways

  • MFN protects relative terms, not a minimum return or the best imaginable deal.
  • A SAFE's MFN can import a later discount or valuation cap without another investment from the original investor.
  • Covered transactions, exclusions and notice requirements determine when the right applies.
  • An MFN is not itself a valuation cap. Read what it lets the holder adopt.

How it works

A supplier's MFN might promise a customer the lowest price offered to comparable buyers. The contract needs to define "comparable": the same product, order volume, service level and period.

In startup financing, an MFN often appears in an uncapped, no-discount SAFE. It lets an early investor adopt eligible terms from a later convertible financing. The investor accepts uncertain economics today in exchange for protection if the company offers better terms later.

The acronym alone does not tell you whether changes are automatic, require an election or cover only certain provisions.

A later discount gives the early investor 50,000 more shares

An investor puts $200,000 into an uncapped, no-discount SAFE with an MFN. Later, the company issues a discount-only SAFE with a 20% discount.

The first investor elects to adopt the later SAFE's terms. At the priced round, new investors pay $1 per share. There are no other conversion-price adjustments.

Early investor's conversionWithout MFN protectionWith the MFN election
Conversion price$1.00$1.00 × 80% = $0.80
Calculation$200,000 ÷ $1.00$200,000 ÷ $0.80
Shares issued200,000250,000

The early investor receives 25% more shares for the same check. Those extra 50,000 shares dilute founders and other holders, even though the company receives no additional cash from that investor.

This is not a 25-percentage-point ownership increase. Final ownership depends on the full cap table and the new round.

What the document says

YC's US "Safe: MFN, no Valuation Cap, no Discount" form requires notice of subsequent convertible securities and lets the investor elect to amend the SAFE to adopt a preferable instrument's terms.

The election adopts the later instrument as a package. It is not permission to select its best clauses while rejecting the rest. The form also defines which subsequent securities qualify.

For diligence, keep the original SAFE, later instruments, notices and amendments together. A cap table alone does not show the contractual right.

What to question

Question an MFN that reaches unrelated side letters, has no clear end point or lets the holder import favorable provisions without the accompanying obligations.

Check whether employee equity, lender instruments and strategic arrangements are excluded. Also check how notice must be delivered and how the investor makes an election. A protection that exists on paper can still create a dispute over procedure.

MFN versus a valuation cap

ProtectionWhat it doesWhat it does not do
MFNAllows adoption of eligible later termsSet a conversion valuation ceiling by itself
Valuation capLimits the valuation used to calculate a conversion priceAutomatically give the holder better terms offered later

A SAFE can contain both, but neither implies the other.

Questions founders ask

What is the concept of the most favoured nation?

The central idea is equal treatment relative to a defined group, not special treatment for one favorite. A contract defines that group; international trade agreements establish their own nondiscrimination rules and exceptions.

What are the exceptions to the Most-Favoured-Nation clause?

In contracts, exceptions are whatever the agreement excludes, such as specified securities or investor-specific rights. In international trade, separate WTO rules permit exceptions such as qualifying free-trade areas and customs unions. Those trade exceptions do not govern startup SAFEs.

What is MFN in private equity?

In private equity funds, MFN usually means a side-letter right that lets a limited partner elect eligible terms granted to other investors. Eligibility can depend on commitment size, with exclusions for tax, regulatory or investor-specific provisions. This differs from a startup SAFE's conversion protection.

Are MFN clauses enforceable?

In the US, they can be, subject to contract law and competition law. Commercial pricing MFNs can attract antitrust scrutiny if they restrict competition. A financing MFN's enforceability depends on its drafting, governing law and circumstances.

Related terms

Sources

  1. Y Combinator, "Safe Financing Documents," US MFN form and Safe User Guide.
  2. World Trade Organization, "Principles of the trading system."
  3. Institutional Limited Partners Association, "ILPA Principles 3.0," June 2019.
  4. US Department of Justice, complaint in United States v. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan, October 18, 2010.