Participating preferred

Also called participating preferred stock or participating preference shares.

Deals and equity8min read

Participating preferred is preferred stock that receives its stated preference and then shares in additional distributions alongside common stock. In US venture deals, this usually means taking a liquidation preference first, then sharing in the remaining exit proceeds.

In broader corporate finance, participation can also refer to extra dividends. This page focuses on liquidation participation in US startup financing: how the proceeds from a sale or liquidation are divided.

Key takeaways

  • A 1x participating investor gets its investment back first, then takes its ownership percentage of the remaining proceeds.
  • "1x" describes the initial preference, not the investor's maximum payout.
  • A participation cap can limit the preferred-stock payout, but conversion to common stock may let the investor receive more than that cap.
  • Participation changes the founders' exit proceeds without changing the ownership percentages shown on the cap table.
  • Liquidation preferences govern distributions to stockholders. They do not put preferred investors ahead of the company's creditors.

How participating preferred works

A liquidation preference gives preferred stockholders priority over common stockholders when proceeds are distributed. Participation determines whether preferred holders also share in what remains after that priority payment.

For a company with one preferred class, the payout follows these steps:

  1. Determine the proceeds available to stockholders after debt and transaction costs.
  2. Pay the preferred stock's liquidation preference, subject to the money available.
  3. Divide the remaining proceeds among preferred and common holders on an as-converted basis.
  4. Apply any participation cap and account for the investor's right to convert to common stock instead.

"As-converted" means calculating ownership as though the preferred shares had converted into common shares. If the investor owns 20% on that basis, it receives 20% of the residual pool, not another 20% of the original sale price.

This two-step payment is often called "double dipping." It is one contractual payout formula, not two separate investments.

The preference multiple and participation right are independent terms. A 1x participating preference and a 2x non-participating preference create different outcomes. Neither the word "preferred" nor the multiple alone tells you the full economics.

A $20 million exit pays the investor $5.6 million, not $4 million

An investor puts in $2 million for 20% of the company on an as-converted basis. Founders own the remaining 80%.

The comparison below uses a 1x liquidation preference, no dividends, no participation cap, and no other securities. Exit proceeds mean cash available to stockholders after debt and transaction costs, before stockholders' personal taxes.

For non-participating preferred, the investor chooses between its preference and conversion to common stock, whichever pays more.

Exit proceedsNon-participating: investorNon-participating: foundersParticipating: investorParticipating: founders
$1 million$1 million$0$1 million$0
$5 million$2 million$3 million$2.6 million$2.4 million
$10 million$2 million$8 million$3.6 million$6.4 million
$20 million$4 million$16 million$5.6 million$14.4 million
$50 million$10 million$40 million$11.6 million$38.4 million

At the $20 million exit, participating preferred pays:

  • Initial preference: 1 × $2 million = $2 million.
  • Remaining proceeds: $20 million − $2 million = $18 million.
  • Participation: 20% × $18 million = $3.6 million.
  • Total investor payout: $2 million + $3.6 million = $5.6 million.

With non-participating preferred, the investor converts and receives 20% × $20 million = $4 million.

Participation therefore transfers $1.6 million from the founders to the investor in this example. The investor receives 28% of the exit proceeds despite owning 20% on an as-converted basis.

For exits of at least $2 million, the uncapped participating payout is:

Investor payout = $2 million + 20% × (exit proceeds − $2 million)

Once conversion is preferable for the non-participating investor, the dollar gap between the two structures stays at $1.6 million under these assumptions. Participation does not disappear at a successful exit; it becomes smaller relative to the total proceeds.

How a 3x participation cap changes the result

Now add a 3x cap on the investor's total payout while it remains preferred. The cap includes the initial preference.

For the same $2 million investment:

Total preferred payout cap = 3 × $2 million = $6 million.

The investor compares its capped preferred payout with what it would receive by converting to common stock.

Exit proceedsCapped participating investor receivesReason
$20 million$5.6 millionPreference plus participation remains below $6 million
$25 million$6 millionThe uncapped payout would be $6.6 million; the cap applies
$50 million$10 millionConversion produces 20% × $50 million, more than the capped payout

At $25 million, the uncapped calculation is $2 million + 20% × $23 million = $6.6 million.

The cap is not necessarily an absolute ceiling on the investor's return. Above a $30 million exit, 20% ownership produces more than $6 million, so conversion pays more under these terms.

Read what the cap includes. A cap on total proceeds is different from a cap only on the additional participation. Also check whether accrued dividends count toward it.

What the financing documents say

The NVCA Model Term Sheet presents alternatives for non-participating preferred, fully participating preferred and capped participating preferred. These alternatives describe different ways to distribute proceeds after the initial preference.

The corresponding rights belong in the company's operative charter documents. For a Delaware corporation, review the certificate of incorporation, including any applicable certificate of designations, rather than relying on the term sheet alone.

In the NVCA Model Certificate of Incorporation, liquidation provisions address distributions and specified "deemed liquidation" events. These can include certain mergers or sales of substantially all assets. The document also addresses conversion separately.

Three details deserve particular attention:

  • Which transactions trigger the preference, and who can waive its application.
  • Whether participation uses the same as-converted ownership calculation as your model.
  • Whether caps, dividends and conversion rights work together as the term sheet suggests.

A founder's sale of personal shares is not automatically a company liquidation event. Nor does participation automatically entitle an investor to a share of ordinary operating profits.

Before another financing, give prospective investors the current charter, an accurate cap table and an exit waterfall. A cap table shows ownership; the waterfall shows who gets paid at different sale prices.

What to negotiate before signing

A 1x preference appears in the NVCA Model Term Sheet's drafting alternatives, but a model document is not a survey of market frequency. The important distinction is not whether a term appears in a standard form. It is what that term costs in your deal.

A founder-friendly negotiating baseline is 1x non-participating preferred: the investor gets downside priority without also sharing in the remainder. If an investor asks for participation, model it before trading it against valuation or other terms.

Focus on these points:

  • Preference multiple. In the example above, changing 1x to 2x would raise the initial priority payment from $2 million to $4 million, subject to available proceeds.
  • Participation cap. Specify whether the cap includes the initial preference and dividends. A 3x cap only on additional participation could allow $2 million of preference plus $6 million of participation, rather than $6 million total.
  • Priority between rounds. Senior preferred gets paid before junior preferred. Equal-ranking classes may share an insufficient preference pool under the charter's allocation rules.
  • Dividend accruals. If accrued dividends are included in the liquidation amount, a model based only on the original investment understates the priority claim.

Participating versus non-participating preferred

Both structures can have a liquidation preference and conversion rights. Participation is the difference in how the remaining proceeds are allocated.

FeatureParticipating preferredNon-participating preferred
Initial preferencePaid before common, subject to available proceedsPaid before common, subject to available proceeds
Shares in the remainder while staying preferredYes, subject to any capNo
Investor's economic choiceParticipation payout versus conversion payoutPreference payout versus conversion payout
Participation capPossibleNot applicable
Founder effect in the exampleLess cash at intermediate and large exits without a capMore cash once the investor converts

Questions founders ask

What is the difference between participating and non-participating preferred shares?

Participating preferred receives its preference and then shares in the remaining proceeds. Non-participating preferred receives its preference or converts to common stock for its ownership-based share, rather than receiving both. "Preference shares" is another name for preferred shares, so the same distinction applies.

What is the difference between a participating and non-participating liquidation preference?

This describes the payout right rather than the stock class as a whole. A preferred share has several rights, including voting and conversion rights. Its liquidation provisions determine whether the holder participates after receiving its preference. Calling stock "preferred" does not, by itself, establish participation.

What is the difference between participating preferred and convertible preferred?

They describe separate features and are not opposites. "Participating" concerns distributions; "convertible" means the preferred stock can become common stock under specified terms. Preferred stock can be both participating and convertible. Conversion matters especially when a participation cap makes the common-stock payout more attractive.

Should a founder accept participating preferred?

Price the cost before deciding. Compare exit waterfalls for the actual offers, including ownership, preference multiples, caps, dividends and seniority. Participation may be an acceptable trade for other financing terms, but "only 1x" is not a sufficient reason to accept it. The example shows why: a 1x participating investor receives $5.6 million on a $2 million investment at a $20 million exit.

Related terms

Sources

  1. National Venture Capital Association, "Model Legal Documents," Term Sheet.
  2. National Venture Capital Association, "Model Legal Documents," Certificate of Incorporation.
  3. Delaware General Assembly, Delaware General Corporation Law, 8 Del. C. § 151.