Peer review

Business basics2min read

Peer review is the evaluation of work by people with relevant expertise. In research, experts assess papers, often before publication. In business, colleagues review work such as code, forecasts or reports to find errors and improve quality.

How peer review works

The author shares the work, reviewers check it against relevant standards, and the author responds to feedback or makes revisions. Reviewers should explain what is wrong and why, rather than simply approve or reject it.

In academic publishing, reviewers advise the journal's editor, who decides whether to publish. At work, peer review might happen before code is released or a financial model reaches the board. In employee performance reviews, it means feedback from colleagues rather than only a manager.

Peer review is a quality check, not a guarantee that the work is correct.

Catching a $110,000 cash forecast error

A startup has 100 customers, each paying $100 monthly. All pay on time, with no annual prepayments. The founder's draft forecast mistakenly treats annual recurring revenue (ARR) as cash collected this month.

A finance colleague checks the model:

MeasureCalculationAmount
Monthly recurring revenue100 × $100$10,000
Annual recurring revenue$10,000 × 12$120,000
Cash collected this month100 × $100$10,000

The review catches a $120,000 − $10,000 = $110,000 overstatement of monthly cash receipts. It does not change the business's revenue; it stops the founder from planning spending against money the company has not collected.

Questions people ask

What are the 5 key elements of peer review?

There is no universal five-part standard across research and business. A practical checklist is relevant expertise, clear review criteria, fair judgment, specific feedback and an opportunity to revise. That is a useful framework, not an official definition.

Is it "peer-reviewed" or "peer review"?

Use "peer review" for the process: "The forecast went through peer review." Use "peer-reviewed" to describe work that underwent it: "a peer-reviewed paper." Calling something peer-reviewed does not tell you how thorough the review was.

Related terms

Sources

  1. Elsevier, "What is peer review?"
  2. GitHub Docs, "About pull request reviews."