Quasi-contract

Also called a contract implied in law.

Business basics2min read

In US law, a quasi-contract is an obligation imposed by a court to prevent someone from unjustly benefiting at another's expense, even though no contract was agreed. The remedy is restitution, not enforcement of a promise.

How it works

The claimant must show why the recipient's benefit is unjust, not just that the claimant lost money. Requirements vary by state.

Recovery focuses on the benefit that should be returned, rather than the profit an agreed deal would have produced. Doing someone an unsolicited favor does not automatically create a right to payment.

Recovering a $4,000 mistaken payment

Your startup accidentally transfers $4,000 to an unrelated business that supplied nothing. The recipient knows the payment was a mistake and refuses to return it. There is no contract between the businesses.

If no defense applies, restitution restores the mistaken payment:

ItemAmount
Money received by mistake$4,000
Amount recipient was entitled to receive$0
Restitution$4,000 - $0 = $4,000

This is different from seeking compensation for a supplier's failure to deliver under an actual contract.

The American Law Institute's Restatement (Third) of Restitution and Unjust Enrichment, §§ 1-2, describes liability for unjust enrichment and explains that a valid contract controls matters within its scope.

That means quasi-contract generally cannot be used to rewrite an unfavorable bargain or bypass its agreed payment terms.

Questions people ask

What is the difference between a contract and a quasi-contract?

An express or implied-in-fact contract rests on agreement. An implied-in-fact agreement is shown through conduct rather than explicit words. A quasi-contract requires no agreement: the law imposes the obligation to prevent unjust enrichment.

Are quasi-contracts enforceable?

Yes. A court can order restitution once the claimant proves the applicable legal requirements. A quasi-contract is not a signed document, but the resulting judgment is enforceable.

Sources

  1. American Law Institute, Restatement (Third) of Restitution and Unjust Enrichment, §§ 1-2, 2011.
  2. Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute, Wex, "Quasi contract."