Red herring

Deals and equity2min read

A red herring is something that distracts attention from the real issue. In US finance, the term has a separate meaning: a preliminary prospectus circulated for a securities offering before the registration statement becomes effective.

When a positive metric dodges the question

A true fact can still be a distraction. Consider these hypothetical monthly results:

MetricLast monthThis month
Revenue$100,000$80,000
Website visits20,00030,000

Revenue fell 20%: ($80,000 - $100,000) / $100,000 = -20%.

Visits rose 50%: (30,000 - 20,000) / 20,000 = 50%.

An investor asks why revenue fell. The founder answers, "Website traffic grew 50%."

Traffic is the red herring in that exchange. It might matter to the business, but it does not explain the lost revenue. A better answer identifies what drove the decline, then explains whether those extra visitors are likely to become customers.

The finance meaning

In a US public offering, a red herring gives prospective investors information about the business and proposed offering before the final terms are set. It often includes an expected price range rather than a final offering price.

The nickname comes from the red warning legend on the cover. Regulation S-K, Item 501(b)(10), calls for a warning that the information is incomplete and may change, and that sales cannot occur before the registration statement becomes effective.

For a startup raising a private seed round, "red herring" is not another name for a pitch deck or private placement memorandum.

Questions people ask

What does "red herring" mean in simple terms?

It means a distraction from the question that matters. It need not be a lie: a true statement becomes a red herring when used to sidestep the issue.

Does the SEC approve a red herring?

No. The SEC does not approve an offering's merits. A registration statement becoming effective is not an endorsement of the investment or a guarantee that its disclosures are accurate.

Related terms

Sources

  1. Merriam-Webster, "red herring."
  2. US Securities and Exchange Commission, Regulation S-K, Item 501(b)(10).
  3. US Congress, Securities Act of 1933, Section 23.