Reference check
A reference check is a conversation or questionnaire used to confirm someone's past work and learn how they performed, usually by asking former managers or colleagues. Employers use it in hiring; investors also check founders' references.
Key takeaways
- Ask for examples tied to the job, not a general verdict on whether someone is "good."
- Get the candidate's permission before contacting a current employer.
- Treat one vague negative comment as a reason to investigate, not proof.
- A reference check and a background check answer different questions, although their legal treatment can overlap.
How a reference check works
Start with the requirements of the role. A first sales hire needs different evidence from a finance manager.
Confirm how the reference knows the candidate, when they worked together and whether they directly observed the relevant work. Then ask consistent questions across finalists:
- "What results were they personally responsible for?"
- "Tell me about a commitment they missed. What happened next?"
- "Would you hire them again, and for which role?"
Record examples and context rather than impressions alone. A former manager's reluctance to speak might reflect company policy, not poor performance. Give the candidate a chance to explain a material discrepancy before deciding.
A $25,000 cost of restarting a hire
Your startup is hiring an operations lead at a hypothetical $120,000 annual salary. Interviews suggest the finalist has managed people, but a reference explains that they coordinated contractors without supervising employees.
That is a gap to test, not an automatic rejection.
If a failed hire meant paying two months of salary and incurring another $5,000 in recruiting costs, the direct cost would be:
| Item | Calculation | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly salary | $120,000 ÷ 12 | $10,000 |
| Two months of salary | $10,000 × 2 | $20,000 |
| Additional recruiting costs | Hypothetical expense | $5,000 |
| Total | $20,000 + $5,000 | $25,000 |
This excludes payroll taxes, benefits and lost time. References cannot guarantee that you avoid this cost. Here, they tell you to test management ability before making the offer, or narrow the role to match the candidate's experience.
What the screening paperwork means
The FTC and EEOC's Background Checks: What Employers Need to Know explains the requirements when an employer obtains a report from a consumer reporting company.
For employment reports covered by the Fair Credit Reporting Act, employers must provide a standalone written disclosure and obtain written authorization before ordering the report. Additional procedures apply before an adverse hiring decision based on it.
An ordinary direct reference call is not automatically a consumer report. A third-party reference-check report can be covered, so a generic permission form is not a substitute for the required screening paperwork.
Reference check versus background check
| Check | Main question | Common inputs |
|---|---|---|
| Reference check | How did this person work? | Observations from managers, colleagues or clients |
| Background check | Do specified facts or records check out? | Employment, education, identity or criminal-record checks, depending on scope |
Neither label guarantees a particular scope. Ask what the employer or screening provider actually checks.
For founders, references run both ways
Investors check founders' references, but founders should also check prospective investors.
Ask to speak with founders whose companies struggled, not just the portfolio's successes. Useful questions include whether the investor honored commitments, helped during a cash shortage and handled disagreement constructively.
The reference should match the decision: a founder who received a small check without board involvement cannot tell you much about that investor's behavior as a board member. Specific examples matter more than a glowing recommendation.
Questions founders ask
What is a reference and background check?
Employers sometimes use this phrase for a package containing both checks. It does not describe one standardized process. Ask which records will be searched, who will be contacted and whether a third-party screening company is involved.
What will disqualify you on a background check?
There is no universal list. A false credential, missing required license or relevant misconduct can affect a hiring decision. A criminal record is not an automatic ban from every job. Applicable law, the duties involved and restrictions for regulated roles matter.
How does Checkster check references?
Checkster, offered by Harver, gathers reference feedback through online questionnaires and compiles it for the employer. Candidates provide reference contact details. It collects assessments of past work rather than simply searching criminal records; the employer still has to evaluate the feedback.
Should I check references before or after offering a job?
Check at the finalist stage, before an unconditional commitment. A conditional offer can leave references outstanding if that condition is explicit. Criminal-history inquiries have separate timing rules in some jurisdictions, so do not assume every background check belongs at the same stage.
Related terms
Sources
- Federal Trade Commission and Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, Background Checks: What Employers Need to Know, March 2014.
- US Office of Personnel Management, Reference Checking.
- Harver, Reference Checking.
- Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, Enforcement Guidance on the Consideration of Arrest and Conviction Records in Employment Decisions under Title VII, April 25, 2012.
