Restrictive covenant

Deals and equity4min read

A restrictive covenant is a clause in an agreement or deed that limits what a person or business may do. It can restrict competition, property use or borrowing. Whether it is enforceable depends on the restriction and the applicable law.

Key takeaways

  • The term covers restrictions in employment agreements, property documents and financing contracts. The rules differ across these settings.
  • Signing a restriction does not automatically make it enforceable. State law matters, especially for employment noncompetes.
  • For founders, a covenant can limit hiring, borrowing or a sale. Read the exceptions, consent requirements and consequences of a breach, not just the prohibition.

How restrictive covenants work

A restrictive covenant identifies a prohibited activity, who is bound and who can enforce it. Some expire on a stated date; others continue until released or terminated under the document.

In property documents, covenants can limit construction, commercial use or other activities on the land. Some bind later owners, not just the person who originally agreed. They are separate from zoning rules imposed by government.

In employment agreements, the phrase often covers noncompetes, nonsolicitation clauses and confidentiality obligations. These are different restrictions: protecting confidential information does not necessarily require banning someone from joining a competitor.

In financing agreements, restrictions often concern additional borrowing, dividends or asset sales. A loan restriction might require lender consent before the company takes a specified action. Equity investors' approval rights are usually called protective provisions.

A $400,000 loan exceeds the permitted borrowing by $150,000

A hypothetical startup owes $500,000 in loan principal. Its agreement caps total loan principal at $750,000 unless the lender gives written consent. No exceptions apply, and the company plans no repayments before borrowing again.

ItemAmount
Existing loan principal$500,000
Maximum principal without consent$750,000
Remaining borrowing capacity$250,000
Proposed additional loan$400,000
Amount above the limit$150,000

The available capacity is $750,000 − $500,000 = $250,000. Taking the full new loan would bring principal to $900,000, which exceeds the cap by $150,000.

The founder needs written consent, a smaller loan or another permitted funding source. Equity could cover the gap, but would dilute existing owners. Borrowing without consent can breach the agreement even if every payment is on time. The lender's remedies, including any right to demand early repayment, depend on the default and cure provisions.

What the document says

California Business and Professions Code section 16600(a) states:

"Except as provided in this chapter, every contract by which anyone is restrained from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind is to that extent void."

California generally voids employment noncompetes. Statutory exceptions include qualifying sales of a business under section 16601. A founder selling company ownership should not assume the rules for an ordinary employee noncompete answer the question.

This is not a US-wide rule. Other states apply different laws, and property or financing restrictions require a different analysis.

What to question before signing

Check the restricted activity, duration, exceptions, approval process and remedy. Ask whether consent must be written and whether it can be withheld for any reason.

For a loan, inspect the definition of "Indebtedness." It may reach guarantees or certain lease obligations, not just cash loans. For an employment restriction, question language that reaches customers you never dealt with or work unrelated to the employer's business. Narrower wording still needs to comply with state law.

Before investor diligence, collect the signed agreements, amendments and waivers that could restrict the company or its financing. Flag required consents before a planned closing depends on them.

Restrictive covenant vs. noncompete

TermMeaning
Restrictive covenantThe broader category, covering restrictions in employment, property and financing documents
NoncompeteA specific restriction on working for or operating a competing business

A noncompete is one kind of restrictive covenant. A borrowing limit is not a noncompete.

Questions people ask

What is a restrictive covenant?

It is a provision that limits someone's actions, such as using property for commercial purposes, competing with a former employer or taking on additional debt. Its legal effect depends on the document and applicable law.

What is an example of a restrictive covenant?

A loan agreement might prohibit a company from borrowing above $750,000 without the lender's written consent. A property declaration might prohibit commercial use of a residential lot. Neither example is automatically enforceable merely because it appears in a document.

What does covenant restriction mean?

It usually means a restriction imposed by a covenant, rather than a separate legal category. Identify exactly what conduct is restricted, who can enforce the restriction and whether it binds later owners or other parties.

What are the three types of restrictive covenants?

There is no universal set of three. In employment discussions, people often mean noncompetes, nonsolicitation clauses and confidentiality clauses. Property and financing documents use different categories, so that shorthand does not describe every restrictive covenant.

Sources

  1. Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute, Wex, "Restrictive covenant."