Unfunded liability

Metrics and finance2min read

An unfunded liability is the portion of an obligation not covered by assets set aside to pay it. The term most often describes a pension plan whose estimated benefit obligations exceed its assets.

How it works

For a defined-benefit pension, the liability estimates today's value of future benefit payments. Plan assets are the investments held to meet those promises. A plan can have substantial assets and still have an unfunded liability.

The shortfall changes with investment performance, discount rates and assumptions about future payments. A lower discount rate increases the estimated liability, all else equal.

A pension plan with a $3 million shortfall

At the same valuation date, an illustrative pension plan has these figures:

MeasureAmount or calculation
Present value of benefit obligations$12 million
Plan assets$9 million
Unfunded liability$12 million − $9 million = $3 million
Funded ratio$9 million ÷ $12 million = 75%

The plan is 75% funded, not empty. The $3 million gap does not mean $3 million is payable immediately. For an employer, the contribution schedule determines how much cash must go into the plan rather than hiring, expansion or distributions.

What the accounts show

For US government employers, GASB Statement No. 68 defines the net pension liability as the total pension liability minus the plan's fiduciary net position.

Corporate accounting and pension funding valuations use different measurement rules. Check the report's basis before comparing two reported shortfalls.

Questions people ask

What triggers withdrawal liability?

A complete or partial employer withdrawal from a US multiemployer pension plan can trigger withdrawal liability. A complete withdrawal generally means permanently ending the obligation to contribute or all covered operations. The charge concerns the employer's allocated share of unfunded vested benefits, subject to statutory rules and exceptions.

Related terms

Sources

  1. Governmental Accounting Standards Board, Statement No. 68, "Accounting and Financial Reporting for Pensions", June 2012.
  2. US Code, Title 29, Sections 1381 and 1383, "Withdrawal liability established" and "Complete withdrawal".