Value engineering
Also called VE.
Value engineering is a structured method for improving a product, service or project by examining its required functions and finding ways to deliver them at lower total cost or with better performance. It is not simply choosing the cheapest option.
How it works
Start with the function, not the existing design. A package needs to "protect product"; it does not necessarily need a plastic insert.
Compare alternatives against required performance, quality and safety. Include life-cycle costs such as maintenance, failures and disposal, not just the purchase price.
A common shorthand is value = function ÷ cost. This frames the trade-off; it is not a standardized accounting ratio.
Replacing a packaging insert saves $25,000
In this illustrative example, a manufacturer ships 100,000 units annually. A folded-cardboard insert passes the same protection tests as its plastic insert. Damage rates and other costs stay unchanged.
| Cost | Current plastic insert | Cardboard alternative |
|---|---|---|
| Insert per unit | $0.80 | $0.50 |
| New tooling | $0 | $5,000 |
| First-year total | $80,000 | $55,000 |
First-year savings = 100,000 × ($0.80 − $0.50) − $5,000 = $25,000.
The saving comes from changing how the protection function is delivered. Removing the insert without checking damage rates would be a cost reduction, but not necessarily a value improvement.
Questions people ask
What are the five phases of value engineering?
There is no universal five-phase list. SAVE International's value methodology uses six workshop phases: information, function analysis, creative, evaluation, development and presentation. Preparation comes before the workshop; implementation and follow-up come afterward. Five-phase descriptions combine or label steps differently.
Is value engineering cost cutting?
It can reduce costs, but cost reduction alone is not the test. An alternative must preserve required functions and performance. Better reliability at the same cost can also improve value. A cheaper component that causes more repairs can destroy it.
