Variable interest entity

Also called a VIE.

Business basics4min read

A variable interest entity (VIE) is a legal entity whose funding or ownership rights trigger a US GAAP control test based on decision-making power and economic exposure, rather than voting ownership alone. Its primary beneficiary must include it in consolidated financial statements.

In Chinese-stock investing, "VIE structure" also describes arrangements that use contracts to control an operating business without direct equity ownership. Those arrangements add ownership and contract-enforcement risks.

Key takeaways

  • VIE is an accounting classification, not a legal form like an LLC or corporation.
  • A company can consolidate a VIE without owning any of its shares.
  • Control requires both power over the most important activities and potentially significant exposure to losses or benefits.
  • Consolidation includes the VIE's assets and liabilities, not just a percentage matching the investor's ownership.

How the control test works

Under US GAAP's ASC 810, the analysis has two stages.

First, determine whether the entity is a VIE. Triggers include insufficient equity at risk to finance its activities without additional subordinated financial support. Another trigger is that the equity investors, as a group, lack decision-making power, an obligation to absorb expected losses, or rights to expected residual returns.

Second, identify the primary beneficiary. That is the reporting entity with both:

  • Power to direct the activities that most significantly affect the VIE's economic performance.
  • An obligation to absorb losses, or a right to receive benefits, that could potentially be significant to the VIE.

Neither financing the entity nor managing routine operations is enough by itself. A VIE can also have no primary beneficiary if no party meets both conditions.

A $950,000 loan creates consolidation without share ownership

A company starts with $2 million in cash and no liabilities. It lends $950,000 to a separate server-owning entity. Outside shareholders contribute $50,000, and the entity buys $1 million of equipment.

The outside shareholders have no substantive decision-making rights. The company's contract gives it sole power over customer selection and server pricing, the activities that drive the entity's performance. Its loan exposes it to potentially significant losses.

The entity is a VIE because its equity holders lack decision-making power. The company is its primary beneficiary despite owning no shares.

Ignoring fees, taxes and interest, selected balance-sheet amounts are:

ItemCompany alone, after financingConsolidated group
Cash$1,050,000$1,050,000
Loan receivable from VIE$950,000$0
Server equipment$0$1,000,000
Total assets$2,000,000$2,050,000
Noncontrolling interest$0$50,000

The arithmetic is $2,000,000 − $950,000 = $1,050,000 of remaining cash. Consolidated assets are $1,050,000 + $1,000,000 = $2,050,000.

The loan receivable and the VIE's matching loan payable cancel on consolidation. The outside shareholders' $50,000 remains as noncontrolling interest within equity.

What the accounting guidance says

FASB's ASC 810-10-25-38A assesses whether potential losses or benefits could be significant to the VIE, not whether they are significant to the investor.

In the example, assess the $950,000 exposure against the server entity's economics. A large investor cannot dismiss an interest merely because it is small relative to its own balance sheet.

VIE versus special purpose vehicle

TermWhat it describesMain question
Variable interest entityAn accounting classification under ASC 810Who, if anyone, must consolidate it?
Special purpose vehicle (SPV)An entity established for a limited purposeWhat activity or assets does it hold?

An SPV can be a VIE, but the labels are not interchangeable. A separate incorporation certificate does not establish separate accounting treatment.

What founders should question

Before calling an SPV's debt "off balance sheet," ask for an ASC 810 assessment. Neither a small ownership percentage nor separate incorporation settles the issue.

For fundraising diligence, share the ownership chart, financing contracts and consolidation analysis together. Consolidation changes financial reporting, not legal ownership or which entity owes a debt.

Questions people ask

What is a variable interest in an entity?

It is an ownership, contractual or other financial interest that absorbs some of the entity's economic variability. Equity, loans and certain guarantees can qualify. Holding a variable interest does not automatically make someone the primary beneficiary: the power test must also be met.

Where does NCI go on the balance sheet?

Nonredeemable noncontrolling interest appears within equity on the consolidated balance sheet, separately from equity attributable to the parent. In the example, the outside shareholders' $50,000 is NCI even though the consolidating company owns none of the VIE's shares. Certain redeemable interests require different presentation.

Related terms

Sources

  1. Financial Accounting Standards Board, Accounting Standards Codification Topic 810, "Consolidation," including paragraphs 810-10-15-14, 810-10-25-38A and 810-10-45-16.
  2. Financial Accounting Standards Board, ASC 480-10-S99-3A, SEC staff guidance on redeemable securities.
  3. US Securities and Exchange Commission, Gary Gensler, "Statement on Investor Protection Related to Recent Developments in China," July 30, 2021.