409A valuation
Also called a Section 409A valuation.
A 409A valuation estimates the fair market value of a private company's common stock for U.S. tax purposes. Startups use it to set stock option exercise prices. It is not the company's fundraising valuation or a guaranteed sale price.
Section 409A is a broader U.S. tax law governing nonqualified deferred compensation. The valuation takes its name from that law. Employees also encounter it when reviewing equity offers: it helps explain their option strike price, but not what their shares will eventually be worth.
Key takeaways
- A 409A valuation supports the price of common stock. Investors often buy preferred stock with different rights, so their price is not a substitute.
- An independent appraisal can provide a legal "safe harbor": a presumption that the valuation is reasonable, not IRS approval.
- A valuation more than 12 months old cannot support new grants under these rules. Material new information can make it stale sooner.
- A supportable lower valuation reduces employees' exercise costs. An artificially low one creates tax risk.
- A discounted option that fails Section 409A can expose its holder to income before exercise, a 20% additional federal tax and a premium-interest charge.
How a 409A valuation works
For an ordinary private-company option to qualify for the usual exemption from Section 409A, its exercise price must be at least the underlying stock's fair market value on the grant date. Other requirements also apply.
409A Valuation Providers help private companies determine the fair market value of their common stock through independent valuations. Choosing an experienced provider ensures the valuation is properly documented and supports compliance with applicable IRS requirements.
That creates a practical question: what is a share worth when there is no stock exchange quoting its price?
A valuation provider answers it through several steps.
1. Review the company and its financing
The provider requests the cap table, financial statements, forecasts, governing documents and details of recent or pending transactions. Preferred-stock rights, SAFEs, convertible notes and the option pool affect the analysis.
Give the provider material information, including bad news. An appraisal based on an outdated cap table or forecasts management no longer believes is not a strong defense.
2. Estimate the business's equity value
The provider selects methods appropriate to the company. These can include comparisons with other businesses, analysis of expected future cash flows, or an asset-based approach.
A recent financing is important evidence, but it does not automatically establish the value of every share class.
3. Allocate value to common stock
Preferred investors may have liquidation preferences and other rights that common shareholders lack. The provider accounts for those differences when allocating value among share classes.
A discount for lack of marketability may also be appropriate because private shares cannot readily be sold. That discount needs support; it is not a standard percentage founders can select.
4. Approve grants using current information
The company uses the supported common-stock value when setting exercise prices. The board or an authorized delegate still needs to approve grants properly.
The appraisal does not issue options, approve an equity plan or correct defective grant paperwork.
How a lower strike price saves $40,000
Consider two alternative grants of 50,000 options, each covering one common share. One occurs before a genuine increase in common-stock value; the other occurs afterward, using an updated appraisal.
Both scenarios end with a sale that pays $5 per common share after any preferred-stock payout rules. Taxes and fees are excluded.
| Item | Earlier grant | Later grant |
|---|---|---|
| Supported common-stock value per share | $0.80 | $1.60 |
| Exercise price per option | $0.80 | $1.60 |
| Number of options | 50,000 | 50,000 |
| Exercise cost | $40,000 | $80,000 |
| Proceeds from selling the shares | $250,000 | $250,000 |
| Proceeds minus exercise cost, before tax | $210,000 | $170,000 |
The exercise costs are:
- Earlier grant: 50,000 × $0.80 = $40,000.
- Later grant: 50,000 × $1.60 = $80,000.
The lower strike leaves the holder with $40,000 more before tax. It also makes exercising less expensive if the employee wants to acquire shares before a sale.
These are alternative grants, not two prices management can choose between. A company cannot ignore material information already available just to preserve the lower price. And a later appraisal does not automatically change the strike price of options already granted.
The table also does not show take-home pay. Option type, exercise timing and the eventual sale determine the tax treatment.
What the report and grant documents say
Treasury Regulation §1.409A-1 describes private-stock fair market value as a value determined by the "reasonable application of a reasonable valuation method."
The important word is not just "method." Applying a legitimate method to incomplete or unrealistic information can still produce an unreasonable result.
A useful report identifies:
- The valuation date and common-stock value per share.
- The financial information and capitalization used.
- The valuation methods and allocation among share classes.
- Material transactions and assumptions.
- Any marketability discount and its basis.
The valuation date matters more than the date the PDF arrives.
The grant approval and option agreement do a different job: they establish the grant's terms, including the number of shares and exercise price. An offer letter promising options is not necessarily the grant itself. Do not backdate approvals to capture an older valuation.
Keep the report, supporting records and grant approvals together. Investors or a buyer reviewing the company's equity history may ask whether option prices were supported when grants were made.
How long a valuation stays usable
The Treasury regulation rejects a previously calculated value if it is more than 12 months old. It also rejects reliance on an earlier calculation that fails to reflect later information that may materially affect company value.
Twelve months is therefore an outside limit, not a guaranteed shelf life.
A new financing, meaningful acquisition interest or a major change in business performance can require a fresh assessment before further grants. A signed financing term sheet can matter before the round closes. Tell the provider and counsel what is happening rather than treating closing day as the only relevant date.
The 12-month rule is not a standalone requirement to buy a report every year regardless of activity. It limits reliance on an old valuation. New grants, option exercises and financial reporting can create reasons to obtain current valuation support.
What safe harbor protects
An independent appraisal is one route to a presumption of reasonableness under the Treasury regulations. To overcome that presumption, the IRS must show that the valuation is grossly unreasonable.
That is valuable protection, but it has limits:
- It is not an IRS certificate or advance approval.
- It does not protect an appraisal that ignores material information.
- It does not fix unrelated problems with option terms or grant procedures.
- It does not guarantee that an auditor or buyer will accept every conclusion without questions.
The regulations provide other safe-harbor methods, subject to specific conditions. An outside appraisal is not universally mandatory. For a venture-backed company with several share classes, however, an independent appraisal provides a clearer basis for defending the common-stock value than an unsupported internal estimate.
If a discounted option fails Section 409A, the consequences fall primarily on the holder. Vested compensation can become taxable before exercise, with the additional federal tax and premium-interest charge. State tax consequences can add to that burden.
What to accept and what to question
A common-stock value below the latest preferred financing price is not, by itself, a problem. The securities have different rights.
There is no legally fixed ratio between those prices. A large gap needs an explanation, not an automatic rejection or automatic acceptance.
Question a report that:
- Uses a cap table that omits outstanding securities.
- Does not address a recent financing or another material transaction.
- Applies a marketability discount without explaining its basis.
- Relies on forecasts that contradict the board's current operating plan.
- Promises a desired result before reviewing the company's information.
Ask the provider to explain the bridge from company value to common-stock value. Do not ask it to reverse-engineer a low strike price.
409A valuation versus fundraising valuation
| Question | 409A valuation | Fundraising valuation |
|---|---|---|
| What is it for? | Support common-stock fair market value, including option pricing | Set the economic terms of an investment |
| Which security matters? | Usually common stock | Often preferred stock in a priced round |
| What is the output? | A supported value per common share | A negotiated pre-money or post-money value and investment price |
| Who establishes it? | The company, supported by valuation analysis | The company and investors through negotiation |
| Is it an exit promise? | No | No |
A high fundraising valuation does not require an identical common-stock value. Equally, a low 409A valuation does not mean the company must accept that value when negotiating its next round.
Questions founders ask
How much does it cost to get a 409A valuation?
There is no government-set fee or universal market price. Quotes depend on the company's complexity, the provider and what the service includes. Ask whether the price covers report revisions, updates after financing and audit support. If a valuation comes with a software subscription, compare the total subscription cost with a standalone report rather than treating the appraisal as free.
Why do you want a low 409A valuation?
A supportable lower value allows a lower exercise price for new options. That reduces the cash employees need to exercise and increases their potential pre-tax gain at the same eventual sale price. But lower is not always better: an indefensible valuation puts holders at risk, and a low strike does not make an unsuccessful company's shares valuable.
What is a 409A valuation for a business?
It is a tax-focused valuation of the relevant stock, usually a private company's common shares. It is not an appraisal of what the whole business could sell for. For a startup, the distinction matters because preferred shareholders can have rights that make their shares more valuable than common shares. The appraisal also does not determine whether an option qualifies as an ISO or a nonqualified option.
How long does it take to get a 409A valuation?
There is no IRS approval queue: the provider prepares the appraisal. Turnaround depends on its workload, the company's complexity and whether the records are complete. Get a written delivery estimate measured from receipt of all required information, then leave time to review the report before approving grants. A pending financing or unclear preferred-stock terms can require more analysis.
Sources
- U.S. Department of the Treasury, Treasury Regulation §1.409A-1, particularly paragraphs (b)(5)(i) and (b)(5)(iv)(B), published in the Electronic Code of Federal Regulations.
- U.S. Congress, Internal Revenue Code §409A, "Inclusion in gross income of deferred compensation under nonqualified deferred compensation plans," particularly subsection (a).
- Internal Revenue Service, "Topic no. 427, Stock options."
