Stock option

Also called a share option.

Deals and equity8min readStock option calculator

A stock option gives its holder the right, but not the obligation, to buy or sell shares at a specified price under agreed terms. An employee stock option is a right to buy the employer's shares.

The context matters. Options traded through a brokerage are investment contracts: a call gives its buyer the right to buy shares; a put gives the right to sell. Employee options are compensation, not freely tradable securities. This page focuses on employee options at US companies.

Key takeaways

  • An option is not a share. You become a shareholder when you exercise the option and receive shares.
  • Vesting earns you the right to exercise. It does not remove the exercise cost, tax bill or expiration date.
  • A private company's estimated share value is not cash you can withdraw. You need a permitted sale to turn shares into money.
  • Incentive stock options (ISOs) and nonstatutory stock options (NSOs) have different federal tax rules.
  • A grant's share count stays fixed unless adjusted under its terms. Its percentage of the company falls when the company issues more shares.

How an employee stock option works

An employee option moves through four stages.

  1. Grant. The company approves an award with a share count, exercise price, vesting schedule and expiration date. The exercise price, also called the strike price, is what you pay per share.
  2. Vesting. You earn the right to exercise through continued service or specified milestones. Leaving before a cliff date can mean no options vest.
  3. Exercise. You use vested options to buy shares at the strike price. Exercising usually requires cash and can create tax obligations.
  4. Sale. You sell the shares through an acquisition, public market or permitted private transaction. Private-company shares often have transfer restrictions, and a buyer might not exist.

Some plans permit early exercise before vesting. The resulting shares remain subject to restrictions, and the tax analysis changes.

For private companies, a "409A valuation" helps establish the fair market value of common stock for option pricing. It is not an offer to buy your shares. The price investors paid for preferred stock in the latest financing is not automatically the value of employee common stock.

Turning 20,000 options into $140,000 before tax

Consider an NSO grant covering 20,000 shares at a $1 strike price. The award vests over four years, with 25% vesting after the first year and the rest monthly over the following 36 months. This schedule is an example, not a legal requirement.

All options have vested when an acquisition closes. The buyer pays $8 per common share, after any preferred-stock claims, and the employee exercises and sells all the shares at closing. Ignore transaction fees.

ItemCalculationAmount
Exercise cost20,000 × $1$20,000
Sale proceeds20,000 × $8$160,000
Gain before tax and fees$160,000 − $20,000$140,000

The employee does not receive $160,000 of profit. The $20,000 exercise cost comes first. The transaction might allow that cost to be deducted from sale proceeds, but the employee should not assume that feature exists.

For this same-day NSO exercise and sale, the $140,000 spread is generally compensation income, not a long-term capital gain.

The percentage can shrink without the grant changing

At grant, suppose the company has 2 million fully diluted shares, including outstanding shares, options and the reserved option pool. The grant represents:

20,000 ÷ 2,000,000 = 1%

A financing then adds 500,000 shares, with no other changes:

20,000 ÷ 2,500,000 = 0.8%

The employee still holds 20,000 options at a $1 strike. The financing diluted the potential ownership percentage.

For a founder, the same denominator matters. Hiring from an already-counted option pool does not add further dilution on that fully diluted basis. Increasing the pool does.

ISO and NSO tax treatment

IRS Topic 427 distinguishes statutory options, including ISOs, from nonstatutory options. For standard exercises of vested employee options:

  • ISOs: Exercise generally creates no regular federal income tax, but the spread can create an alternative minimum tax (AMT) adjustment. Favorable sale treatment requires holding the shares for more than one year after exercise and more than two years after the option grant.
  • NSOs: At exercise, the difference between the shares' fair market value and the exercise price is generally compensation income. Employee payroll taxes and withholding generally apply. Later changes in share value produce capital gain or loss when the shares are sold.

ISOs are restricted to employees. NSOs can also be granted to consultants and directors.

The dangerous combination is exercise, tax and no liquidity. An employee can owe tax on an NSO exercise without being able to sell the shares. An ISO exercise can also produce an AMT bill while the company remains private.

A later fall in share value does not simply erase the earlier tax event.

What the grant documents say

An offer letter's promise of equity is not the same as an approved option award.

Look for the equity incentive plan, the individual award agreement and the formal grant approval. GitLab's publicly filed 2021 Equity Incentive Plan illustrates the structure: the plan establishes general rules, while award agreements supply grant-specific terms.

Read these together to identify:

  • The number of shares and strike price.
  • The vesting start date, cliff and treatment of a leave of absence.
  • The final expiration date and any shorter deadline after employment ends.
  • Whether early exercise or vesting acceleration is allowed.
  • What happens in an acquisition, including whether awards are assumed, cashed out or canceled under the plan's rules.

For a financing, reconcile approved grants, promised grants and the unused pool with the cap table. Keep the plan, award agreements and approval records ready for investor diligence. An unapproved hiring promise can become an unexpected ownership dispute.

What's normal and what to question

There is no single standard option package. Separate tax requirements from negotiable employment terms.

Strike price

Treasury Regulation § 1.409A-1(b)(5) generally requires an exercise price at least equal to grant-date fair market value for a compensatory stock option to qualify for the usual stock-option exemption from Section 409A.

Question a discounted strike price presented as a free benefit without tax analysis. Also question pricing based solely on a preferred financing round without considering the rights attached to that stock.

Vesting and departure

The agreement should state when vesting begins and what happens when service ends. Check whether a promised vesting start date actually appears in the approved award.

Find the post-termination exercise deadline before accepting the grant. A long final expiration date does not guarantee that long to exercise after leaving. The contract can impose a much earlier deadline.

Ownership and exit value

Ask for both the share count and the fully diluted denominator used to calculate a percentage. "One percent" without a measurement date and denominator is incomplete.

For founders discussing compensation, show a scenario rather than promising a payout. Preferred-stock liquidation preferences, future dilution and the eventual sale price all affect what common shareholders receive.

Stock options versus shares and RSUs

InstrumentWhat the holder hasPayment to receive shares
Employee stock optionA right to buy shares under the award's termsExercise price, plus applicable taxes
Share of stockActual ownership, sometimes subject to vesting or repurchase rightsDepends on how the share was acquired
Restricted stock unit (RSU)A contractual promise to deliver shares or cash when settlement conditions are metNo exercise price, but taxes can apply
Exchange-traded stock optionA tradable contract to buy or sell sharesBuyer pays a premium; exercise obligations depend on the contract

An option holder generally lacks shareholder voting rights until exercise. An RSU is also not an issued share before settlement.

Questions founders ask

What is a stock option?

For an employee, it is the right to purchase company shares at a specified exercise price under an award agreement. It is potential ownership, not an immediate shareholding or a guaranteed payment.

How does a share option work?

"Share option" is another name for a stock option. Under an employee award, the holder earns exercise rights through vesting, pays the strike price to acquire shares and receives any sale proceeds later. Unexercised options can expire even after they have vested.

What is the $100,000 rule for stock options?

Under Internal Revenue Code § 422(d), only $100,000 of underlying stock value can first become exercisable as ISOs for an individual in a calendar year across the employer's, parent's and subsidiaries' plans. Value is measured at grant, not exercise. If 60,000 options first become exercisable this year and grant-date fair market value was $2 per share, the total is $120,000. With no other grants using the allowance, 50,000 options fit the ISO limit and 10,000 are treated as NSOs. Earlier grants use the allowance first.

How do stock options make money?

For an employee, money comes from selling acquired shares for more than the exercise cost, taxes and fees. Vesting alone pays nothing. A higher private-company valuation creates a paper gain, not necessarily a sale opportunity.

What happens to options when an employee leaves?

Unvested options are usually forfeited under the award's terms. Vested options remain exercisable only for the period allowed by the agreement. Separately, ISO tax rules generally require exercise within three months after employment ends to retain ISO treatment. That is not a universal contractual deadline. Special rules apply to disability and death.

Should employees exercise before an exit?

There is no automatic answer. Earlier exercise can start a holding period and reduce the taxable spread if the share value is low, but it puts cash at risk in an illiquid company. Compare the exercise cost, tax exposure, deadline and ability to lose the full investment. A valuation increase is not enough reason on its own.

Related terms

Sources

  1. Internal Revenue Service, "Topic no. 427, Stock options."
  2. Internal Revenue Service, "Publication 525, Taxable and Nontaxable Income."
  3. United States Code, Title 26, § 422, "Incentive stock options."
  4. US Department of the Treasury, Treasury Regulation § 1.409A-1(b)(5).
  5. GitLab Inc., "2021 Equity Incentive Plan," filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission, 2021.