Equity compensation

Also called stock-based compensation or share-based compensation.

Deals and equity4min readStock option calculator

Equity compensation is pay in company shares or rights linked to their value, rather than cash salary or fees. Common forms include stock options, restricted stock and restricted stock units (RSUs).

Key takeaways

  • An option is a right to buy shares at a fixed exercise price, not ownership of those shares.
  • Vesting determines how much of an award you earn. It does not guarantee that you can sell it.
  • Compare grants by fully diluted ownership percentage, exercise costs and departure terms, not share count alone.
  • For founders, expanding the option pool dilutes existing holders. Grants from a pool already included in the fully diluted share count do not add further dilution on that basis.

How equity compensation works

The equity plan and individual award agreement set the rules: what you receive, when it vests and what happens if you leave.

TypeWhat you receiveMain distinction
Stock optionsA right to buy shares at a stated strike priceYou must exercise to become a shareholder
Restricted stockShares subject to forfeiture or repurchase restrictionsYou own shares before they fully vest
Restricted stock units (RSUs)A promise to deliver shares or cash when settlement conditions are metThe grant itself is not stock ownership

Vesting often depends on continued service. A cliff delays the first vesting date; performance conditions can also apply.

Private-company shares may remain unsellable for years. US tax treatment differs by award type, and equity can create a tax bill before there is cash to pay it. Incentive stock options and nonstatutory stock options have different tax rules.

10,000 options can produce $40,000, not $50,000

A hypothetical employee receives 10,000 options with a $1 strike price. All options vest and are exercised. The shares are later sold for $5 each, the amount common shareholders actually receive after any claims ahead of them.

ItemCalculationAmount
Exercise cost10,000 × $1$10,000
Sale proceeds10,000 × $5$50,000
Gain before taxes and fees$50,000 − $10,000$40,000

This excludes taxes and fees. It also requires the employee to fund the exercise unless another permitted payment method is available.

Ownership percentage can shrink along the way. If the grant represents 10,000 of 1,000,000 fully diluted shares, it starts at 1%. Issuing 250,000 new shares to investors reduces it to 10,000 ÷ 1,250,000 = 0.8%, with no other changes. Vesting does not prevent dilution.

What the documents say

SEC Rule 701 provides a registration exemption for qualifying private-company compensation grants under written compensatory plans or contracts. That exemption does not make the resulting shares freely tradable.

The award agreement should identify the award type, quantity, vesting conditions and, for options, exercise price and expiration rules. Read its departure provisions closely: vested options can still expire if they are not exercised within the applicable period.

Before a funding round, reconcile the equity plan, grant approvals and award agreements with the cap table. Investors reviewing ownership need those records to agree.

What's normal and what to question

Vesting and transfer restrictions are ordinary features of startup equity. A guaranteed future payout is not.

Question a grant described only as a share count or a projected dollar value. Ask for the fully diluted percentage, exercise deadline after departure and any conditions that delay settlement. The latest preferred-share financing price is not interchangeable with the value of employee common stock.

For founders, equity does not remove payroll costs. It trades some cash compensation for ownership and requires accurate records.

Questions founders ask

What is equity compensation?

It is payment for work through shares or share-linked rights. Unlike buying stock in a funding round, receiving an equity grant is part of compensation, although exercising an option can require an investment of cash.

Is equity compensation good?

It can provide upside, but private-company equity is not spendable salary. Evaluate the cash offer separately, then consider whether you can afford exercise costs and potential taxes without a guaranteed opportunity to sell.

What is an example of equity compensation?

A startup employee might receive salary plus stock options, as in the example above. A public-company employee might receive RSUs that settle in shares after vesting. Neither award guarantees a future sale price.

Related terms

Sources

  1. US Securities and Exchange Commission, Rule 701, 17 CFR § 230.701.
  2. Internal Revenue Service, "Topic no. 427, Stock Options."
  3. Internal Revenue Service, Publication 525, "Taxable and Nontaxable Income."