Vesting
Vesting is the process of earning the right to keep a benefit, such as employer retirement contributions, company shares or stock options. An unvested benefit can be forfeited if you leave before meeting the plan's conditions.
A vesting schedule sets out when those rights are earned. This page uses US rules: retirement-plan vesting and startup equity vesting share the same basic idea, but their legal rules differ.
Key takeaways
- Vesting is not the same as exercising an option or selling shares. You can be fully vested and still have no cash payout.
- Cooley GO describes four-year vesting with a one-year cliff as a common startup schedule. It is a convention, not a legal requirement.
- Founders often receive shares upfront, subject to a company right to repurchase the unvested portion if they leave.
- Your own 401(k) salary-deferral contributions and their earnings are immediately vested. Employer contributions can follow a separate schedule.
- For restricted stock, a Section 83(b) election has a deadline of 30 days after the stock transfer, not after vesting begins.
How vesting works
A company or retirement plan promises a benefit, then attaches conditions to keeping it. Those conditions usually involve continued service, although equity awards can also depend on performance.
For startup equity, the instrument matters:
- Stock options give you the right to buy shares at an exercise price. Vesting earns that right; exercising uses it. Some plans permit early exercise before vesting, with the resulting shares subject to repurchase.
- Restricted stock consists of shares already issued to you, but subject to restrictions. For founders, the company often has a right to repurchase unvested shares at their original purchase price when service ends.
- Restricted stock units, or RSUs, promise a future delivery of shares or cash. Vesting and delivery, called settlement, need not happen at the same time.
Founder restricted stock is often described as "reverse vesting." You own the shares from the start, while the company's repurchase right shrinks as you complete service.
The grant date and vesting commencement date are not necessarily identical. An agreement might credit service before the grant, but that credit must appear in the documents.
Cliff, graded and performance-based vesting
A cliff is a period before any vesting occurs. Under a four-year schedule with a one-year cliff, someone who leaves before the first anniversary normally receives no vested equity from that award.
Graded vesting releases portions over time. A startup award can combine both patterns: a portion vests at the first anniversary, then the rest vests monthly.
Performance-based vesting depends on a defined result, such as a revenue target or product milestone. The agreement should specify who measures the result, the deadline and what happens if the target is only partly met.
Hybrid awards combine service and performance conditions. Do not treat a performance target as a substitute for reading the service requirement.
Leaving after 18 months: what you keep
An employee receives 48,000 options with a $1 exercise price. The award vests over 48 months, with a 12-month cliff and monthly vesting afterward. Service starts on the vesting commencement date, with no acceleration.
The underlying monthly rate is:
48,000 options ÷ 48 months = 1,000 options per month
Nothing vests before the cliff. At month 12, the first 12 months vest together.
| Departure after completed service | Vested options | Unvested options forfeited | Cost to exercise all vested options |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11 months | 0 | 48,000 | $0 |
| 12 months | 12,000 | 36,000 | $12,000 |
| 18 months | 18,000 | 30,000 | $18,000 |
| 24 months | 24,000 | 24,000 | $24,000 |
| 48 months | 48,000 | 0 | $48,000 |
At month 18, 18,000 ÷ 48,000 = 37.5% of the award is vested.
If the shares are then worth $5 each, the vested options have a paper spread of:
18,000 × ($5 − $1) = $72,000
That is not a $72,000 cash payment. The employee still needs to exercise, account for any tax consequences and find a permitted opportunity to sell. The options also have an exercise deadline.
For a founder, the same schedule works differently. A founder who bought 4.8 million restricted shares would have 1.8 million vested shares after 18 months. The remaining 3 million could be repurchased under the agreement. At an original purchase price of $0.0001 per share, a repurchase at cost would return just $300.
That is why founder vesting is an ownership issue, not just an HR detail.
What the documents say
The NVCA model term sheet includes stock-vesting provisions that describe staged vesting and company repurchase rights over unvested shares. Those model terms are negotiable. The signed stock-purchase agreement, option agreement and equity plan determine the actual rights.
Read the documents for:
- The vesting commencement date, cliff and installment frequency.
- What happens to unvested equity when service ends.
- Whether vested options expire sooner after departure.
- Any acceleration, repurchase rights or special treatment for termination for cause.
For restricted stock, Internal Revenue Code Section 83 supplies the tax framework. Compensation income is generally measured when the shares vest. A Section 83(b) election instead permits the recipient to include the stock's value at transfer, minus the amount paid, in income at that earlier time.
The election must be filed within 30 days after the stock transfer. A low purchase price or zero taxable spread does not extend that deadline. The election does not apply to an ordinary unexercised option grant.
During financing diligence, investors often review signed founder stock agreements alongside the cap table. Ownership totals alone do not show how much stock remains subject to repurchase.
What's normal and what to question
Cooley GO describes four-year vesting with a one-year cliff as a common startup arrangement. That is a useful reference point, not a requirement for every founder, employee or adviser.
Question these terms before signing:
- A restart that ignores past service. Investors might request new founder vesting in a financing. Ask how much credit you receive for work already completed.
- An unclear departure rule. "Leaving" could mean resignation, dismissal, disability or the end of consulting work. The agreement should distinguish the relevant cases.
- Rights over vested shares. Ordinary vesting does not explain every repurchase or forfeiture clause. A provision allowing the company to take back vested shares needs separate attention.
- A short exercise window. Vested options can expire after employment ends. Vesting does not preserve them indefinitely.
- A milestone someone can change. Performance vesting is weak protection if the company can redefine success after the work is done.
A schedule that looks generous can still produce a poor result if the departure and exercise terms are harsh.
What happens when the company is sold?
A sale does not automatically accelerate vesting.
Single-trigger acceleration requires one specified event, often a change of control. Double-trigger acceleration usually requires both a change of control and a qualifying termination within a defined period.
The wording matters more than the label. Check whether resignation for "good reason" qualifies, what counts as a change of control and whether the buyer must assume or replace the award.
Also check what happens if the buyer does not assume the equity. The agreement can treat that situation differently from an acquisition where the award continues.
How vesting works in a 401(k)
For a US 401(k), your own salary-deferral contributions and their earnings are always 100% vested. Vesting schedules concern employer contributions, such as matching contributions, where the plan permits delayed vesting.
Consider an account with:
- $10,000 from your own contributions.
- $5,000 from employer contributions.
- A 40% vested percentage for the employer portion.
Ignoring investment gains and losses, the vested balance is:
$10,000 + ($5,000 × 40%) = $12,000
If you leave before further vesting, the remaining $3,000 of employer contributions is subject to forfeiture under the plan's rules.
Being vested does not mean you can withdraw retirement money whenever you want without tax consequences. Ownership rights and distribution rules are separate. Read the plan's summary plan description for the schedule and how service is counted.
Startup stock schedules are not governed by the same vesting rules as 401(k) plans.
Vesting versus exercise and liquidity
| Term | What happens | What it does not guarantee |
|---|---|---|
| Vesting | You earn rights under the award or plan | Cash, a buyer or unrestricted transferability |
| Exercise | You use an option to buy shares | An immediate profit or sale |
| Liquidity | You have an opportunity to turn an asset into cash | A particular price or favorable tax treatment |
A fully vested founder can still be unable to sell. Private-company shares often have transfer restrictions, and a buyer may not exist.
Questions founders ask
What does "vesting" mean in finance?
It means earning a right to a financial benefit under specified conditions. In retirement plans, that usually means the right to keep employer contributions. In startup equity, it means earning rights to shares or options through service or performance. Vesting does not itself turn either benefit into spendable cash.
What does "2 year vesting" mean?
It usually means the award becomes fully vested over two years, but the phrase does not specify the installments. A 24,000-option award could vest at 1,000 options per month for 24 months, or all at once after a two-year cliff. Those schedules produce very different outcomes if you leave after one year. Ask for the actual schedule.
What is the meaning of "vested"?
A vested benefit is one you have earned under the applicable conditions. For founder stock, the company's service-based repurchase right has lapsed over the vested portion. For options, you have earned an exercise right, but it still has an expiration date. Other contractual restrictions can remain.
What are the two types of vesting?
People often mean cliff vesting and graded vesting. A cliff delays vesting until a specified date; graded vesting releases portions over time. Startup awards commonly combine them. Another distinction is time-based versus performance-based vesting, which describes the condition you must satisfy rather than the installment pattern.
Related terms
Sources
- Cooley GO, "What Is Vesting?"
- National Venture Capital Association, Model Legal Documents, "Term Sheet."
- United States Code, Title 26, Section 83, "Property transferred in connection with performance of services."
- Internal Revenue Service, Publication 525, "Taxable and Nontaxable Income."
- Internal Revenue Service, "Retirement Topics: Vesting."
