Cliff vesting

Deals and equity8min read

Cliff vesting is a schedule with a waiting period before someone earns the right to keep equity or employer-funded retirement benefits. Nothing vests before the cliff; a specified portion vests at once when it arrives.

The phrase has two common uses in the US: startup equity and retirement plans. A startup's one-year cliff usually releases the first portion of an award. A retirement plan's three-year cliff releases all covered employer contributions at once. Those are different schedules, despite sharing the same name.

Key takeaways

  • Four-year vesting with a one-year cliff means 25% vests at the first anniversary, with the rest commonly vesting monthly over the next three years.
  • The vesting commencement date controls the clock. It is not necessarily the grant date or your first day at work.
  • Founder shares can be issued before they vest. The company usually has a contractual right to repurchase the unvested shares if the founder leaves.
  • Your own 401(k) contributions are always fully vested. Employer contributions can have a separate vesting schedule.
  • Vesting is not the same as cashing out. Options still require exercise, and private-company shares may have no available buyer.

How a startup cliff works

A vesting schedule ties an equity award to continued service. The cliff is the first release point: service before that date does not produce a vested portion unless the agreement says otherwise.

For the four-year schedule described in Y Combinator's founder-equity guidance:

  1. Nothing vests during the first year.
  2. One-quarter vests on the first anniversary of the vesting commencement date.
  3. Another 1/48 of the original award vests each month afterward.
  4. The award becomes fully vested after four years of qualifying service.

That is not four-year cliff vesting. A true four-year cliff would release nothing until the fourth anniversary.

Cliffs help prevent someone who leaves early from retaining a large stake based on work they never completed. For founders, that protects the remaining team from having a departed co-founder own a substantial unearned stake.

What is actually vesting?

The instrument matters:

  • Restricted founder stock: The founder already owns the shares, but unvested shares remain subject to the company's repurchase right.
  • Stock options: Vesting earns the right to exercise options. It does not itself make the holder a shareholder. Leaving can start a separate exercise deadline.
  • Restricted stock units, or RSUs: The award promises shares or cash under specified terms. Some private-company RSUs require both service and a separate liquidity condition.

A cliff does not override the rest of the agreement. Acceleration, termination provisions and additional vesting conditions can change the result.

Leaving just before or after the first anniversary

A founder buys 480,000 restricted shares for $0.001 each, paying $480 upfront. The shares vest over four years, with a one-year cliff and monthly vesting afterward.

The agreement lets the company repurchase unvested shares at the original purchase price when service ends. There is no acceleration, and the company exercises that right.

The arithmetic is:

  • Monthly portion: 480,000 ÷ 48 = 10,000 shares.
  • First-anniversary release: 10,000 × 12 = 120,000 shares.
  • Remaining shares then subject to repurchase: 480,000 − 120,000 = 360,000.
Departure pointVested shares retainedUnvested shares repurchasedCompany pays to repurchase
One day before the first anniversary0480,000$480
On the first anniversary, after vesting occurs120,000360,000$360
After 13 monthly vesting periods130,000350,000$350
After 24 monthly vesting periods240,000240,000$240
After 48 monthly vesting periods480,0000$0

Crossing the cliff changes the founder's retained stake from zero to 120,000 shares. It does not create a cash payment equal to those shares' market value.

The repurchase price matters just as much as the schedule. Here, the departing founder receives the original cost of the unvested shares, not their later value. A different contractual repurchase provision could produce a different outcome.

What a retirement-plan cliff does

A retirement-plan cliff is usually all-or-nothing for the covered employer contributions, rather than the beginning of monthly vesting.

Under the ordinary federal minimum standards for covered defined contribution plans, an employer can use three-year cliff vesting or six-year graded vesting. Plans can vest benefits faster. Certain safe-harbor contributions have faster vesting requirements.

Completed years of serviceThree-year cliffSix-year graded schedule
10%0%
20%20%
3100%40%
4100%60%
5100%80%
6100%100%

These percentages apply to covered employer contributions and associated earnings, not your salary deferrals. Your own contributions and their earnings are fully vested throughout.

The plan's definition of a year of service matters. Do not assume that its service-crediting rules match a startup's anniversary-based equity schedule.

What the documents say

Section 411(a)(2)(B) of the Internal Revenue Code sets out the three-year cliff and six-year graded alternatives for covered defined contribution plans. Under the cliff alternative, an employee with at least three years of service must have a nonforfeitable right to the covered employer-funded benefit.

For your particular retirement plan, read the summary plan description. It should explain the schedule and how service is counted.

Startup equity has no equivalent federal rule requiring a one-year cliff. Read the grant notice and the option agreement, restricted stock purchase agreement or RSU agreement. Check:

  • Vesting commencement date: When does service start counting?
  • Initial vesting date: Exactly when does the first portion vest?
  • Release amount: How many shares or units vest at the cliff?
  • Later installments: Are they monthly, quarterly or annual?
  • Departure terms: When does service end, and what happens to vested and unvested awards?
  • Repurchase and acceleration: What rights or exceptions change the result?

For fundraising diligence, reconcile these signed agreements with the cap table and relevant board approvals. A spreadsheet showing "25% vested" is not a substitute for the underlying documents.

What's normal and what to question

Y Combinator describes four-year founder vesting with a one-year cliff and monthly vesting afterward as a typical arrangement. That is a startup convention, not a legal requirement or a rule every award must follow.

The headline schedule is only the start of the negotiation.

Credit for work already done

A founder who has already spent substantial time building the company should discuss credit for that service. The vesting commencement date can address this without pretending the grant itself happened earlier.

Check the approved agreement rather than inferring the vesting start from an offer letter or incorporation date.

A reset at the next financing

A financing does not automatically restart an existing cliff. Investors may ask founders to accept a new retention arrangement or re-vesting terms. Ask how previously earned equity is treated and whether prior service receives credit.

Treat a reset as a change in economics, not administrative cleanup.

Departure and acquisition exceptions

Ask what happens if the company terminates you shortly before the cliff. Do not rely on a verbal promise that the board will "take care of it."

If acceleration is offered, identify its trigger. Acceleration upon an acquisition differs from acceleration that requires both an acquisition and a qualifying termination. The agreement should define the events and the amount accelerated.

A longer cliff puts more compensation at risk before the first release. Ask what business problem it solves.

Cliff vesting vs. graded vesting

FeatureCliff vestingGraded vesting
Before the first vesting milestoneNothing vestsPortions vest at scheduled intervals
At a release dateA substantial portion, or everything, vests at onceAnother installment vests
Startup useOften the first stage of a combined scheduleOften follows the initial cliff
Retirement-plan example100% after three yearsIncreasing percentages through six years

The terms are not always opposites. Four-year startup vesting with a one-year cliff combines a cliff with graded vesting afterward.

Reverse vesting describes a different distinction: shares are issued upfront but remain subject to repurchase as they vest. Founder stock can use reverse vesting and still have a cliff.

Questions founders ask

What is four-year vesting with a one-year cliff?

It is a four-year earning schedule with no vesting before the first anniversary of the vesting commencement date. In the common monthly version, 25% vests at that anniversary, followed by 1/48 of the original award each month for another 36 months. The agreement determines the actual dates and conditions.

How long until you're fully vested in a 401(k)?

Your own contributions and their earnings are fully vested immediately. Employer contributions follow the plan's schedule. Under ordinary minimum standards, a plan can use a three-year cliff or graded vesting that reaches 100% after six years. Some plans vest sooner, and certain contribution types have faster requirements.

What does a three-year cliff vesting schedule look like?

For covered employer contributions, it means 0% vested before three years of service and 100% vested upon completing three years. With a $6,000 employer-funded balance, that is $0 vested before the cliff and $6,000 afterward, ignoring investment changes. Your own contributions remain fully vested regardless.

What happens to RSUs that vest after four years?

If four years satisfies all vesting conditions, that grant is fully vested; it does not automatically renew. Share delivery follows the award's settlement terms. Private-company awards with both service and liquidity conditions may still require a qualifying liquidity event. Any new grant has its own schedule.

Related terms

Sources

  1. Y Combinator, Michael Seibel, "How to Split Equity Among Co-Founders."
  2. Internal Revenue Service, "Retirement Topics - Vesting."
  3. U.S. Department of Labor, "What You Should Know About Your Retirement Plan."
  4. U.S. House of Representatives, Office of the Law Revision Counsel, Internal Revenue Code, 26 U.S.C. § 411(a)(2)(B).