Restricted stock

Also called a restricted stock award (RSA) in compensation plans.

Deals and equity4min read

Restricted stock is company stock issued with conditions, usually a vesting schedule and a right for the company to reclaim unvested shares if you leave. It is actual stock, not a restricted stock unit (RSU), which is a promise of future settlement.

US securities law also uses "restricted securities" for certain privately acquired securities with resale limits. Vesting and resale eligibility are separate questions.

Key takeaways

  • You own restricted stock before it vests, but leaving early can mean forfeiting shares or selling them back at the original price.
  • Without an 83(b) election, vesting can create taxable compensation even when you receive no cash.
  • An 83(b) election measures compensation income at transfer instead. The deadline is 30 days after the shares transfer.
  • Fully vested shares are not necessarily shares you can sell. Securities law and company agreements can still limit transfers.

How restricted stock works

A company issues shares under a stock purchase or award agreement. Founders often buy restricted common stock; employees also receive restricted stock as compensation.

The agreement sets the vesting schedule and what happens if service ends. For purchased founder shares, the company often has a right to buy back the unvested portion at its original purchase price. Vesting removes that right over time. Voting and dividend rights depend on the share terms and agreement.

For US federal tax purposes, nontransferable shares subject to a substantial risk of forfeiture generally create compensation income when they vest. The amount is their fair market value then, minus what you paid for those shares.

A timely 83(b) election moves that calculation to the transfer date. It does not remove the vesting conditions.

A $1,000 purchase can create $24,750 of taxable income

A founder buys 100,000 shares for $0.01 each when their fair market value is also $0.01. The purchase costs:

100,000 × $0.01 = $1,000

The shares cannot be transferred free of their forfeiture conditions. They vest 25% each year, and the first 25,000 shares vest when their value reaches $1 per share.

Tax eventNo 83(b) electionTimely 83(b) election
Initial purchaseNo compensation income yet100,000 × ($0.01 − $0.01) = $0 compensation income
First 25,000 shares vest25,000 × ($1 − $0.01) = $24,750 compensation incomeNo additional compensation income from vesting

The $24,750 is taxable income, not the tax bill. The founder owes tax based on applicable rates despite receiving no sale proceeds. Later vesting can create further income without an election.

The election has a downside when the initial value exceeds the purchase price: tax paid on that income is not refunded merely because the shares are later forfeited.

What the documents say

Section 83(b)(2) of the Internal Revenue Code requires an election "not later than 30 days after the date of such transfer." The clock starts when the shares transfer, not when they vest.

In your stock agreement, check the vesting schedule, repurchase price, departure provisions and any acceleration. A repurchase right over unvested shares supports vesting. Question a right to repurchase vested shares at the original price: it can take away value you thought you had earned.

Before financing, reconcile these terms with the cap table and keep signed agreements and 83(b) election records ready for investor diligence.

Restricted stock versus RSUs

PointRestricted stockRestricted stock units
What you receive initiallyActual sharesA contractual right to future shares or cash
Before vestingShares remain subject to forfeiture or repurchase conditionsThe award remains subject to vesting conditions
83(b) electionAvailable for eligible transferred sharesNot available for the units themselves

For an early founder buying low-value shares, the ability to make an 83(b) election is an important difference. An RSU does not become restricted stock merely because both awards have vesting schedules.

Questions founders ask

What happens when I sell restricted stock?

On a permitted sale after vesting, capital gain or loss is generally your sale proceeds minus your tax basis. Basis includes the purchase price and compensation income already recognized under Section 83. A sale before vesting can trigger compensation income, so do not assume all proceeds above your purchase price are capital gains.

What are restricted securities?

Restricted securities are securities acquired through transactions such as private placements that cannot be freely resold publicly. SEC Rule 144 provides one route for eligible resales if its conditions are met. A founder's shares can be fully vested but still subject to securities-law resale restrictions and company transfer limits.

Related terms

Sources

  1. U.S. Code, Title 26, Section 83, "Property transferred in connection with performance of services."
  2. Internal Revenue Service, Publication 525, "Taxable and Nontaxable Income," restricted property section.
  3. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, "Rule 144: Selling Restricted and Control Securities."