Restricted stock unit (RSU)

Deals and equity8min read

A restricted stock unit (RSU) is an employer's promise to deliver company shares, or cash equal to their value, after specified conditions are met. Unlike restricted stock, an RSU is not a share when it is granted.

RSUs are a form of employee compensation. You usually do not pay an exercise price, but receiving the shares can create a tax bill before you sell them. This page covers US practice and federal tax treatment.

Key takeaways

  • Grant, vesting and settlement are separate events. Receiving an award does not mean you own shares or can sell anything.
  • RSUs usually have no exercise price. Taxes still apply, and withholding can reduce the number of shares delivered.
  • Share-settled RSUs generally produce compensation income at settlement. Later changes in the shares' value produce capital gains or losses.
  • Private-company awards may require both service and a liquidity event before they vest. Read what happens if the employee leaves before that event.
  • For founders, RSUs are promises of future compensation that belong in the cap table model. Do not count the same shares both as awards and as unused option-pool capacity.

How RSUs work

An RSU award has three stages.

Grant: the company makes a promise

The grant agreement states the number of units, the vesting conditions and the settlement terms. One unit commonly represents one share, but the agreement controls.

At this point, the employee does not own the underlying shares. There are normally no voting rights. An agreement can provide dividend equivalents, but those are contractual payments, not evidence that shares have already been issued.

Vesting: the conditions are satisfied

Vesting can depend on continued employment, performance or another stated condition. Leaving before vesting usually means forfeiting the unvested award.

Some private-company RSUs require two conditions:

  • A service condition, such as completing a period of employment.
  • A liquidity condition, such as a qualifying IPO or acquisition.

Satisfying the service condition alone might not create an unconditional right to receive shares.

This use of "double trigger" differs from double-trigger acceleration, which can require both a company sale and a qualifying job loss.

Settlement: shares or cash arrive

Settlement is when the company delivers the shares or pays the cash. It often happens at vesting, but the dates can differ.

For share-settled awards, the employer may withhold shares or arrange a sale to cover taxes. A private company cannot assume there will be a market for that sale.

A $100,000 settlement delivers $60,000 of shares after withholding

An employee receives 40,000 RSUs, each representing one share. One-quarter of the award vests and settles when the shares are worth $10 each.

The employer uses an illustrative 40% total withholding rate and withholds shares to cover it. That percentage is an example, not a statutory tax rate.

ItemCalculationResult
Units settling40,000 × 25%10,000
Compensation income10,000 × $10$100,000
Tax withholding$100,000 × 40%$40,000
Shares withheld$40,000 ÷ $104,000
Shares delivered10,000 − 4,0006,000
Value delivered6,000 × $10$60,000

The employee pays no exercise price. The withheld shares fund tax withholding; they are not the purchase price of the award.

The 6,000 delivered shares have a total tax basis of $60,000. If the employee later sells them for $15 each:

  • Sale proceeds are 6,000 × $15 = $90,000.
  • Capital gain is $90,000 − $60,000 = $30,000.

The original $100,000 was compensation income. Only the subsequent $30,000 increase is a capital gain. Withholding is a payment toward the tax bill, not necessarily the final amount owed.

When RSUs are taxed

For a typical unfunded RSU, there is no federal income tax at grant. Compensation income generally arises when shares or cash are delivered. For shares, the taxable amount is their fair market value at delivery, less anything the employee paid.

Payroll taxes also matter. For deferred RSUs, Social Security and Medicare tax timing can differ from income-tax timing. A delayed share delivery does not necessarily delay every employment tax.

IRS Publication 15 permits a 22% federal income-tax withholding method for qualifying supplemental wages up to $1 million for the year. The portion of annual supplemental wages above $1 million is subject to 37% withholding. Payroll and state taxes are separate. These withholding rules do not calculate the employee's final income-tax liability.

After shares are delivered, their subsequent increase or decrease in value produces a capital gain or loss when sold. A holding period of more than one year generally produces long-term capital-gain treatment.

An 83(b) election is not available on an RSU grant because no property has been transferred. Do not confuse this with restricted stock, where actual shares are transferred subject to restrictions.

A particularly bad outcome is possible at a private company: compensation income creates a tax bill, the employee cannot sell the shares, and the shares later fall in value. The later capital loss does not simply reverse the earlier compensation income.

How RSUs affect founder ownership

An RSU grant exchanges future company value for employee service. Unlike an option, it does not require the share price to rise above an exercise price before the award has value.

That can make RSUs attractive to employees at a high private-company valuation. It also makes careful share-count modeling important.

Consider a company with 10 million fully diluted shares, including 8 million founder shares. It adds 500,000 share-settled RSUs outside any pool already included in that denominator.

On a gross-share basis, ignoring net settlement and other changes:

Ownership measureBefore new awardsAfter new awards
Founder shares8,000,0008,000,000
Fully diluted shares10,000,00010,500,000
Founder ownership80%76.19%

The calculation is 8 million ÷ 10.5 million = 76.19%.

If those awards instead come from an unused pool already included in the 10 million shares, the grant does not cause another reduction in fully diluted ownership. The pool's creation or expansion already accounted for that dilution.

Before a financing, reconcile the cap table with the equity plan, approved grants and promised awards. Investors should be able to distinguish outstanding RSUs from unallocated pool capacity.

What the documents say

The equity incentive plan authorizes awards. The individual grant agreement supplies the employee's particular vesting and settlement terms. An offer letter alone rarely answers every important question.

Airbnb's November 2020 Form S-1 describes RSUs with both service-based and liquidity-based vesting conditions. It is a public example of why "I finished my service period" does not necessarily mean "the company must deliver my shares now."

Check these provisions in the actual agreement:

  • Settlement: Is payment due when vesting occurs, on a fixed date or after another event? Can the company settle in cash?
  • Liquidity event: Does the definition cover an IPO, an acquisition or both? A fundraising round does not automatically qualify.
  • Termination: Do awards that satisfied the service condition survive departure while awaiting the liquidity condition? When do they expire?
  • Withholding: Can the company retain shares, require cash or arrange a sale? What happens if selling is impossible?

The tax rules also constrain drafting. Treasury Regulation §1.83-3(e) distinguishes property from an unfunded, unsecured promise to pay money or property later. That distinction helps explain why an RSU grant is not treated like a restricted-stock transfer.

Section 409A governs certain deferred compensation arrangements. An IPO alone is not a permitted payment event for an award subject to those rules. Some RSU designs instead rely on an exemption, such as the short-term deferral exemption. A settlement clause needs tax review, not just a commercially sensible date.

What is normal, and what to question

Public-company RSUs often settle as time-based vesting occurs. Private-company awards may add a liquidity condition to avoid delivering illiquid shares before employees can fund taxes. Neither structure guarantees immediate saleability: trading restrictions and IPO lockups can still apply.

Question an offer that describes only a headline dollar value. Ask for the unit count, the valuation used to calculate it and the conditions for receiving shares.

Also question:

  • A mandatory settlement date at a private company with no credible way to fund withholding.
  • An unclear expiry date or treatment after departure.
  • Language that lets someone describe an award as "vested" while leaving its forfeiture terms unexplained.

For founders, a larger grant is not a substitute for understandable terms.

RSUs vs. restricted stock vs. stock options

FeatureRSUsRestricted stockStock options
What exists at grantPromise of future shares or cashActual shares subject to restrictionsRight to buy shares
Payment to acquire sharesUsually no exercise priceMay require a purchase paymentExercise price
Shareholder rights at grantGenerally noShares carry rights, subject to their termsNo
83(b) election on the grant itselfNoMay be available for unvested sharesNo; early-exercised shares are a separate question

For an early-stage founder, restricted stock and options often provide ways to award equity before the company's value is high. RSUs become more relevant when paying an option exercise price would be a substantial employee expense. The best choice also depends on taxes and whether employees can sell shares.

Questions founders ask

Are RSUs and equity the same?

RSUs are one form of equity compensation, not a synonym for equity. Equity also includes issued shares and other awards, such as stock options. An RSU holder does not own the underlying shares before settlement, and a cash-settled award never creates share ownership.

How do RSU payments work?

The employer delivers shares or cash according to the agreement after the required conditions are met. For share-settled awards, taxes may be covered through share withholding, a sale of some shares or a cash payment from the employee. The remaining shares are delivered to the employee.

Are RSUs subject to capital gains tax?

The award's value generally becomes compensation income when settled, not a capital gain. After shares are delivered, a later sale produces a capital gain or loss measured against their tax basis. Cash-settled RSUs do not leave shares to generate a later capital gain.

Do I need to buy RSUs?

Usually not. Unlike options, RSUs generally have no exercise price. But "no purchase required" does not mean "no cash needed": taxes can require cash if the company cannot withhold shares or arrange a sale.

Related terms

Sources

  1. Internal Revenue Service, Publication 525, "Taxable and Nontaxable Income."
  2. Internal Revenue Service, Publication 15 (Circular E), "Employer's Tax Guide."
  3. US Department of the Treasury, Treasury Regulations §§1.83-3(e), 1.409A-1 and 1.409A-3.
  4. US Department of the Treasury, Treasury Regulation §31.3121(v)(2)-1, special timing rules for nonqualified deferred compensation.
  5. Airbnb, Inc., registration statement on Form S-1, November 16, 2020.