RSUs vs. stock options
Restricted stock units (RSUs) promise shares or cash after specified conditions are met, usually without a purchase payment. Stock options let you buy shares at a fixed exercise price, so their payoff depends on the share price exceeding that cost.
| Difference | RSUs | Stock options |
|---|---|---|
| What you receive | A promise of future shares or cash | A right to purchase shares |
| Purchase cost | Usually none, although taxes still apply | Exercise price, also called the strike price |
| When you become a shareholder | When shares are delivered, for share-settled awards | When you exercise and shares are issued |
| If the share price falls | Still have gross value above zero, provided settlement conditions are met | No gain from exercising at or below the strike price |
| U.S. federal income tax | Generally wage income when shares or cash are delivered | Nonqualified options: generally wage income on the exercise spread. Incentive options have different rules |
| Private-company risk | Vesting might not mean delivery or permission to sell | Exercising can require cash before there is a buyer |
10,000 awards at a $10 sale price
An employee receives either 10,000 share-settled RSUs or 10,000 nonqualified stock options (NSOs) with a $2 strike price.
All vesting conditions are met. The RSUs settle at a sale, and the options are exercised and sold at the same closing for $10 per share. Use a hypothetical 35% federal income tax rate; ignore payroll taxes, state taxes and transaction fees.
| Calculation | RSUs | NSOs |
|---|---|---|
| Shares sold | 10,000 | 10,000 |
| Sale proceeds: 10,000 × $10 | $100,000 | $100,000 |
| Exercise cost | $0 | 10,000 × $2 = $20,000 |
| Taxable compensation | $100,000 | $100,000 − $20,000 = $80,000 |
| Modeled income tax | $100,000 × 35% = $35,000 | $80,000 × 35% = $28,000 |
| Cash after exercise cost and modeled tax | $65,000 | $52,000 |
The RSUs produce $13,000 more after the modeled tax because the employee does not pay the exercise price. No capital gain is modeled because delivery or exercise and sale happen at the same value.
This does not mean an RSU offer is automatically better. Employers can offer different quantities. Compare the actual grants, not one RSU against one option.
When each fits
RSUs: no exercise bill, but watch settlement
RSUs fit compensation packages where employees want equity without funding a purchase. They are particularly useful when the share price would make options expensive to exercise.
At a private company, an RSU award can require both service and a qualifying liquidity event before shares are delivered. That can prevent taxable delivery before an exit, but it creates another condition the employee must satisfy. An IPO or acquisition does not count unless it meets the agreement's definition.
Options: affordable entry with uncertain upside
Options fit early-stage startups where common shares have a low value and substantial potential upside. Employees can participate in future growth without buying shares when the option is granted.
The trade-off is the exercise decision. A low strike can still mean a large cash payment across many shares, plus possible tax. Options can expire without producing anything.
For founders, both awards affect the fully diluted ownership calculation. Exercised options also bring exercise-price cash into the company; RSUs generally do not. That cash difference does not remove the dilution.
What the documents actually promise
Airbnb's November 2020 Form S-1 describes RSUs subject to both service-based and liquidity-based vesting conditions. This is a double-trigger structure, not a promise of freely tradable shares whenever the service condition is satisfied.
For an RSU offer, check:
- When service vesting occurs and when settlement occurs.
- Which liquidity events qualify, and whether the award expires first.
- What survives departure and how tax withholding works.
For options, check the strike price, vesting schedule, final expiration date and post-termination exercise window. Question an offer that supplies only an award count without enough information to understand its cost and ownership percentage.
Before a financing, founders should reconcile both award types with the cap table and share the equity plan, grant agreements and board approvals with investors. Explain how outstanding awards enter the fully diluted share count used in the proposed financing.
Questions people ask
Can I owe tax before I can sell?
Yes. Private-company RSUs can settle, or NSOs can be exercised, before a buyer exists. Federal income tax can then arise on value you cannot turn into cash. RSU payroll-tax timing can also differ from income-tax timing, so a deferred settlement date does not settle every tax question.
How do incentive stock options change the comparison?
Incentive stock options (ISOs) generally create no regular federal income tax at exercise, but the spread can trigger alternative minimum tax. Favorable sale treatment requires holding the shares more than one year after exercise and selling more than two years after grant. The example above uses NSOs, not ISOs.
What happens if I leave the company?
Unvested awards are usually forfeited. Vested options remain exercisable only for the agreement's post-termination window. For double-trigger RSUs, check whether completing the service condition before departure preserves the award until a later liquidity event. Do not assume it does.
