ISO vs. RSU

Deals and equity4min read

An incentive stock option (ISO) lets an employee buy company shares at a fixed price and can qualify for favorable US tax treatment. A restricted stock unit (RSU) promises shares or cash once its conditions are met, without an exercise payment.

DifferenceISORSU
What you receiveAn option to buy sharesA promise to deliver shares or cash
Cash neededExercise price, plus any taxNo purchase price, but taxes may require cash
If the share price fallsThe option has no immediate economic value below its exercise priceDelivered shares retain value unless the share price reaches zero
US federal income taxNo regular income tax at exercise; alternative minimum tax (AMT) is possible. A qualifying sale gets capital-gain treatmentStock or cash value at settlement is ordinary income; later share growth is capital gain
Eligible recipientsEmployees onlyEmployees and other service providers
Main private-company riskPaying to exercise shares you cannot sellReceiving taxable shares you cannot sell, or awards expiring before settlement

The same 10,000 shares can produce similar net proceeds

An employee receives either 10,000 ISOs with a $2 exercise price, equal to grant-date fair market value, or 10,000 RSUs.

All awards vest. Shares are worth $10 when the ISOs are exercised or the RSUs settle, then sell later for $15. The ISO sale meets both holding-period tests: more than two years after grant and more than one year after exercise. The RSU shares are also held more than one year.

Use illustrative tax rates of 37% on ordinary income and 20% on long-term capital gains. Exclude AMT, payroll taxes, net investment income tax, state taxes and fees. Taxes are paid in cash, so all 10,000 shares remain available for sale.

CalculationISORSU
Purchase cost10,000 × $2 = $20,000$0
Sale proceeds10,000 × $15 = $150,000$150,000
Ordinary income tax$0$100,000 × 37% = $37,000
Long-term capital gains tax($150,000 − $20,000) × 20% = $26,000($150,000 − $100,000) × 20% = $10,000
Net after purchase cost and modeled taxes$104,000$103,000

The $1,000 difference is not a rule. Change the exercise price, tax rates or sale price, and the result changes. Equal share counts are not equal grant-date compensation values.

The ISO also creates an $80,000 AMT adjustment at exercise: 10,000 × ($10 − $2). That is extra income in the AMT calculation, not an $80,000 tax bill. Actual AMT and any later credit depend on the employee's return. The table excludes that cash-flow risk.

When each one fits

ISOs: affordable exercise and room for growth

ISOs fit early-stage employee grants when the exercise price is low enough that employees can afford to buy shares and risk losing that money. The potential benefit is capital-gain treatment on appreciation from the exercise price, not just appreciation after exercise.

A low strike price does not make exercise safe. Employees still need money for the purchase and possible AMT, with no guarantee of a buyer.

RSUs: no purchase payment, but settlement matters

RSUs fit grants where exercising options would require substantial cash. They remove the purchase price, not the tax bill.

Private-company RSUs may require both service and a qualifying liquidity event before settlement. This is often called a double-trigger arrangement. An IPO or acquisition is not automatically a qualifying event unless the agreement says so.

For founders, the compensation trade-off matters: replacing 10,000 options with 10,000 RSUs is not a value-neutral swap. Compare hiring value and fully diluted ownership, rather than award counts alone.

What the documents say

Internal Revenue Code Section 422 requires an ISO exercise price at least equal to grant-date fair market value. It also limits ISO treatment to $100,000 per employee of grant-date share value first exercisable in a calendar year, across the relevant company-group plans. Options above that limit receive nonqualified tax treatment.

The equity plan and award agreement supply the operational details:

  • For an ISO, check the exercise price, vesting, post-employment exercise window and expiration date.
  • For an RSU, distinguish vesting from settlement. Check liquidity conditions, settlement deadlines, forfeiture terms and tax withholding.

Question private-company RSU terms that could deliver unsellable shares with an immediate tax bill. A verbal assurance that tax waits until an exit is not enough; the settlement provisions must support it.

For fundraising diligence, reconcile outstanding options and RSUs to the fully diluted cap table, and provide the equity plan and award forms.

Questions people ask

What happens when I leave the company?

For most departures, an ISO must be exercised within three months after employment ends to retain ISO treatment. The agreement may impose a shorter deadline. A longer contractual exercise window does not preserve ISO tax status indefinitely. RSU settlement and expiration follow the award terms; unvested awards are generally forfeited.

Can I make an 83(b) election for RSUs?

No. An RSU is a promise to transfer value later, not a current transfer of property. An 83(b) election does not turn the promise into stock or let you pay tax on its grant-date value. Restricted stock is different from restricted stock units.

Related terms

Sources

  1. Internal Revenue Service, Topic No. 427, "Stock Options."
  2. Internal Revenue Service, Publication 525, "Taxable and Nontaxable Income."
  3. Internal Revenue Service, "Instructions for Form 6251," section on incentive stock options.
  4. U.S. Code, 26 U.S.C. §422, "Incentive stock options."
  5. U.S. Code, 26 U.S.C. §83, "Property transferred in connection with performance of services."