ESPP vs. RSUs

Deals and equity4min read

An employee stock purchase plan (ESPP) lets you buy your employer's shares, often at a discount. Restricted stock units (RSUs) are compensation paid in shares or cash after vesting conditions are met. ESPPs use your money; RSUs do not require a share purchase.

DifferenceESPPRSUs
How you receive sharesBuy them, often through payroll deductionsEarn them under an equity award
Main benefitA purchase discount and sometimes a lookback priceThe full value of the shares delivered
Employee purchase costRequiredNone
Usual federal income-tax eventWhen you sell shares under a tax-qualified planWhen shares are delivered, often at vesting
Exposure to a falling share priceYour purchase money is at risk once you own sharesYour award loses value, but you have not paid to buy it

This page covers US rules and compares a tax-qualified ESPP under Section 423 with share-settled RSUs. Nonqualified ESPPs have different tax rules.

Receiving 100 shares when the price rises from $20 to $30

An employer's share price is $20 when an ESPP offering begins and $30 on the purchase date. Its plan offers a 15% discount on the lower of those two prices, a feature called a lookback.

On the same purchase date, another employee has 100 RSUs vest and settle into shares. Both employees immediately sell all 100 shares for $30 each. Figures below exclude taxes and fees.

The ESPP purchase price is:

$20 × 85% = $17 per share

CalculationESPPRSUs
Shares received100100
Employee purchase payment100 × $17 = $1,700$0
Sale proceeds100 × $30 = $3,000100 × $30 = $3,000
Ordinary compensation income$3,000 − $1,700 = $1,300$3,000
Benefit after purchase cost, before tax$1,300$3,000

The ESPP employee gets $3,000 back, but $1,700 is their own money returned. The immediate sale is a disqualifying disposition, so the $1,300 difference between purchase-date market value and purchase cost is ordinary compensation income. There is no capital gain because the shares sell at their purchase-date market value.

The RSU employee receives $3,000 of ordinary compensation income. Selling immediately at the delivery-date value produces no capital gain.

Equal share counts are not equal compensation packages. The RSUs deliver more value here because the employer supplies the entire share value, not just a discounted purchase opportunity.

When each one fits

An ESPP fits an employee who can commit cash

An ESPP lets employees participate in share ownership through purchases. A discount and lookback can make it attractive, but payroll deductions reduce available cash before the purchase happens.

Check when you can sell. A discount does not protect you from every price drop, and trading windows or plan restrictions can prevent an immediate sale.

RSUs fit employer-funded compensation

RSUs tie compensation to continued service, performance or other conditions without requiring employees to fund a purchase. Employees rarely choose freely between equivalent ESPP and RSU packages: an employer might offer both.

For a private startup, liquidity matters more than the label. Some RSU awards require both service and a liquidity event before vesting or settlement. Read those conditions separately; an award is not cash you can spend.

For founders, both arrangements can dilute existing holders if the company issues new shares. An ESPP also brings purchase cash into the company when it issues those shares. An RSU settlement does not.

What the plan documents should say

Section 423(b)(6) of the Internal Revenue Code permits an ESPP purchase price as low as 85% of the lower market value on the grant date or purchase date. That allows the 15% discount and lookback in the example; it does not require employers to offer either.

Section 423(b)(8) limits purchase-right accrual to $25,000 of grant-date share value per calendar year. This is not a $25,000 limit on payroll deductions or profits.

The ESPP plan and offering documents should explain the discount, lookback, contribution limits, withdrawal rights and sale restrictions. Question any explanation that substitutes "15% discount" for the actual pricing formula.

An RSU award agreement should identify the unit count, vesting conditions, settlement timing and treatment when employment ends. Question any promise that "vested" automatically means "delivered and sellable," especially at a private company.

Questions people ask

Can I have both an ESPP and RSUs?

Yes. They are separate benefits, and receiving RSUs does not by itself prevent ESPP participation. Count both when assessing how much of your wealth depends on your employer, alongside the salary you already depend on.

Are RSUs taxed when they vest?

Often, because vesting and share delivery happen together. Federal income tax generally arises when shares are delivered, based on their market value then. Deferred settlement can change the timing. Payroll withholding is a tax prepayment, not necessarily your final tax bill.

Does holding ESPP shares make the gain tax-free?

No. Favorable disposition treatment requires selling more than two years after the option grant and more than one year after the shares are transferred to you. A qualifying sale can still produce ordinary compensation income; remaining gain receives long-term capital-gain treatment. Holding for tax treatment also leaves you exposed to the share price.

Related terms

Sources

  1. US Congress, Internal Revenue Code, Section 423, "Employee stock purchase plans."
  2. Internal Revenue Service, Publication 525, "Taxable and Nontaxable Income."
  3. Internal Revenue Service, "Topic no. 427, Stock options."
  4. US Congress, Internal Revenue Code, Sections 83 and 409A.