Restricted stock vs. RSUs

Deals and equity4min read

Restricted stock is actual stock issued now, usually subject to forfeiture as it vests. A restricted stock unit (RSU) is a promise to deliver shares or cash later. The biggest differences are ownership timing and access to an 83(b) tax election.

This comparison covers US equity compensation. Here, "restricted stock" means a restricted stock award, not the separate securities-law category of restricted securities.

DifferenceRestricted stockRSUs
What you receive upfrontShares, subject to vesting restrictionsA contractual right to future shares or cash
Default federal income-tax timingAt vesting, on share value minus any purchase priceAt settlement, when shares or cash are delivered
83(b) electionAvailable within 30 days after the stock transferNot available for the RSU itself
Purchase priceSometimes requiredUsually none
Shareholder rightsBegin with ownership, subject to the agreementNo shareholder rights before shares are delivered
Capital-gain holding periodStarts at vesting, or at transfer with an 83(b) electionStarts when shares are delivered; cash settlement produces no stock holding period

How an 83(b) election changes the tax on 10,000 shares

Both awards cover 10,000 shares with no purchase price. The shares are worth $0.10 each at grant, $10 when everything vests two years later, and $15 when sold more than a year afterward.

The restricted-stock recipient files a timely 83(b) election. The RSUs settle in shares immediately upon vesting. For illustration, use a 37% federal rate on compensation and 20% on long-term capital gains. Exclude all other taxes and fees.

CalculationRestricted stock with 83(b)RSUs
Compensation income10,000 × $0.10 = $1,000 at transfer10,000 × $10 = $100,000 at settlement
Tax on compensation$1,000 × 37% = $370$100,000 × 37% = $37,000
Sale proceeds10,000 × $15 = $150,00010,000 × $15 = $150,000
Long-term capital gain$150,000 − $1,000 = $149,000$150,000 − $100,000 = $50,000
Tax on capital gain$149,000 × 20% = $29,800$50,000 × 20% = $10,000
Total modeled tax$30,170$47,000
Proceeds after modeled tax$119,830$103,000

The election saves $16,830 in this rising-value scenario because more appreciation receives capital-gains treatment. It is not free protection: the restricted-stock recipient pays $370 upfront, before knowing whether the company will succeed.

The RSU recipient owes $37,000 at settlement, even if there is no market for the shares. Without an 83(b) election, the restricted stock in this example would also produce $100,000 of compensation income at vesting.

When each one fits

Restricted stock: early ownership at a low value

Restricted stock fits founders and early employees when the common shares still have a low value. A purchase price or an 83(b) tax bill is easier to fund at that point.

The advantage depends on the actual value at transfer, not merely the company's age. A company that has raised substantial capital may already have common stock worth enough to make an upfront purchase or tax bill uncomfortable.

RSUs: no upfront share purchase

RSUs fit situations where buying shares upfront is unattractive, including higher-value private companies and public companies.

For a private-company award, check whether both service and a qualifying liquidity event must occur before vesting and settlement. These are often called double-trigger RSUs. Read what qualifies as a liquidity event and when the award expires. An IPO-related settlement can also create tax while a trading lockup prevents a sale.

What the documents say

Internal Revenue Code Section 83 sets the default tax treatment for restricted stock and permits the 83(b) election. Its deadline is 30 days after the property transfer, not 30 days after the first vesting date.

In a restricted stock purchase or award agreement, identify:

  • The stock transfer date and any purchase price.
  • The vesting schedule.
  • The company's forfeiture or repurchase rights if you leave.

For an RSU award agreement, read vesting and settlement separately. Completing a service requirement does not necessarily mean shares will be delivered immediately. Check liquidity conditions, expiration dates and termination provisions.

For a startup financing, reconcile these agreements with the cap table before sharing equity records with investors. Restricted shares have already been issued; unsettled RSUs have not. But RSUs may still count in the fully diluted capitalization used to price the round. Unissued does not mean non-dilutive.

Questions people ask

Can I make an 83(b) election for RSUs?

No. An RSU is a promise, not a transfer of stock, so the RSU grant itself does not qualify. Do not treat an RSU grant notice as though it were a restricted stock transfer.

What happens if I leave or the shares lose value?

The agreement controls forfeiture, repurchase and RSU survival after departure. If restricted stock is forfeited after an 83(b) election, the compensation included under that election is not deductible merely because of the forfeiture. A later price decline also does not reverse the original compensation income.

Are RSUs the same as stock options?

No. An option gives you the right to buy shares at an exercise price. An RSU generally requires no purchase payment and settles according to its award terms. An option's exercise deadline and an RSU's settlement conditions create different risks.

Related terms

Sources

  1. United States Code, Title 26, Section 83, "Property transferred in connection with performance of services."
  2. Internal Revenue Service, Publication 525, "Taxable and Nontaxable Income."