Nonstatutory stock option (NSO)

Also called a nonqualified stock option (NQSO).

Deals and equity4min read

A nonstatutory stock option (NSO) is a right to buy company shares at a fixed price that does not qualify for special statutory tax treatment. In the US, most private-company NSOs create ordinary taxable income when exercised, even if the shares cannot be sold.

Key takeaways

  • NSOs can go to employees, directors, advisers and contractors. Incentive stock options (ISOs) are limited to employees.
  • Exercising an NSO can create a tax bill before the shares are sellable.
  • The share's tax basis includes the amount taxed as compensation, not just the exercise price.

How NSOs work

An option is a right to buy shares, not ownership. Vesting determines when that right is earned; exercise buys the shares. Most private-company NSOs are not taxed at grant or vesting.

For vested shares, the taxable spread is:

(exercise-date fair market value − exercise price) × shares exercised

For employees, this is wage income subject to withholding and payroll taxes. Early exercise of unvested shares follows separate Section 83 rules, and an 83(b) election can change the tax timing.

A $10,000 exercise creates $40,000 of wage income

A US employee exercises 10,000 vested NSOs at a $1 strike price when the shares are worth $5 each. The employee sells all shares for $8 each more than one year later. Ignore fees.

ItemCalculationAmount
Exercise payment10,000 × $1$10,000
Ordinary wage income10,000 × ($5 − $1)$40,000
Tax basis in the shares$10,000 + $40,000$50,000
Sale proceeds10,000 × $8$80,000
Long-term capital gain$80,000 − $50,000$30,000

The employee must fund the $10,000 purchase plus exercise-related taxes before receiving sale proceeds. The $40,000 taxed as wages becomes part of the share basis, so it is not taxed again as capital gain.

For a founder granting options, this matters to compensation discussions: an employee's paper gain is not spendable cash.

What the documents say

The grant agreement should identify the option type, exercise price, vesting schedule and expiration date.

The IRS General Instructions for Forms W-2 and W-3 require employers to report employee NSO exercise income in the relevant wage boxes and in box 12 under code V. The exercise spread is compensation, even when the stock remains unsold.

Before a financing, reconcile option agreements, board approvals and the cap table. Investors will need the records that support the ownership figures.

What's normal and what to question

Under Treasury Regulation §1.409A-1, an NSO generally needs an exercise price at least equal to grant-date fair market value, plus other conditions, to stay outside Section 409A.

Ask what valuation supports the strike price and when the board approved the grant. Question a discounted strike or a promise of tax-free exercise. A below-market option can trigger Section 409A tax consequences rather than simply provide cheaper shares.

NSOs vs. ISOs

This comparison covers vested shares held after exercise.

FeatureNSOISO
Eligible recipientsEmployees and nonemployeesEmployees only
Federal tax at exerciseOrdinary income on the spreadNo regular income tax; alternative minimum tax can apply
Special qualifying-sale treatmentNoYes, if statutory requirements are met

Questions founders ask

What is statutory vs. non-statutory?

In US stock-option taxation, statutory options qualify under special tax rules. They include ISOs and options under qualifying employee stock purchase plans (ESPPs). Nonstatutory options do not qualify for those rules.

What would cause a non-statutory stock option to be taxable upon a grant?

Grant-date tax can arise when the option itself has a readily ascertainable fair market value and is transferable or vested under Section 83. This is rare for private-company grants. Knowing the value of the underlying shares is not enough.

What are the two types of stock options?

In startup compensation, people usually mean ISOs and NSOs. Qualifying ESPP options are another statutory category, so "two types" is shorthand rather than a complete tax classification.

What is the difference between incentive stock options and nonstatutory stock options?

An ISO's favorable sale treatment requires, among other conditions, holding shares more than two years after grant and more than one year after exercise. NSOs tax the exercise spread as compensation regardless of how long the employee later holds the shares.

Related terms

Sources

  1. Internal Revenue Service, "Topic no. 427, Stock Options."
  2. Internal Revenue Service, Publication 525, "Taxable and Nontaxable Income."
  3. US Department of the Treasury, Treasury Regulation §1.83-7, "Taxation of nonqualified stock options."
  4. US Department of the Treasury, Treasury Regulation §1.409A-1(b)(5), stock rights.
  5. Internal Revenue Service, "General Instructions for Forms W-2 and W-3."