Right of first refusal (ROFR)

Deals and equity8min read

A right of first refusal (ROFR) gives its holder the chance to buy an asset on terms the owner is prepared to accept from another buyer, before that sale goes ahead. The holder can match the offer or pass.

ROFRs appear in real estate, business ownership agreements and other contracts. A tenant might have one over a building; a shareholder might have one over another shareholder's stock. This page focuses on US practice, especially private-company shares.

Key takeaways

  • A ROFR is a matching right, not a standing obligation to buy. It usually becomes relevant when the owner proposes a sale to someone else.
  • In startup stock agreements, the company may have the first purchase right, followed by specified investors. Not every shareholder automatically has one.
  • Matching the price may not be enough. Payment timing, noncash consideration and other material terms matter.
  • A founder's secondary sale puts money in the founder's pocket, not the company's. If the company exercises its ROFR, company cash funds the purchase.
  • Passing on one proposed sale does not necessarily waive the right for a different buyer, lower price or later transaction.

How a ROFR works

The contract determines which transfers trigger the right and what happens next. A typical process has five steps.

  1. The owner proposes a covered transfer. A founder receives an outside offer for shares and decides to pursue it. Merely receiving an unsolicited inquiry does not necessarily trigger anything.
  2. The owner gives notice. The notice identifies the buyer, shares, price and other required terms. Some agreements require supporting documents.
  3. The holder decides whether to exercise. The holder must follow the contract's deadline and notice procedure. Silence has whatever effect the agreement specifies.
  4. Other rights run their course. If the company passes, investors may have a secondary refusal right. A separate co-sale right may also apply.
  5. The permitted sale closes. If no one exercises, the owner can sell to the outside buyer within the agreement's permitted window and on the permitted terms.

There is no universal response deadline. Sequential company and investor response periods can make the total process longer than either period alone suggests.

A ROFR ordinarily does not let its holder force an unwilling owner to start selling. But once the owner triggers the contractual process, a valid exercise can create a binding purchase obligation.

A waiver is also transaction-specific unless it says otherwise. If the outside buyer negotiates a lower price after the holder passes, the revised sale may need to go through the process again.

A $2 million founder sale with three possible buyers

A startup has 10 million outstanding common shares. The founder owns 4 million, or 40%, and proposes to sell 500,000 shares to an outside buyer for $4 per share.

The proposed proceeds are:

500,000 shares × $4 = $2 million

For this example, the ROFR covers the entire proposed block. There are no taxes, fees, options or other share changes. The company has the first right, followed by one investor. Any company repurchase is legally permitted, and the purchased shares are retired.

OutcomeFounder receivesCompany cash spentShares outstanding afterwardFounder's remaining ownership
Both holders pass; outside buyer purchases$2 million$010 million35%
Company passes; investor matches$2 million$010 million35%
Company matches and retires the shares$2 million$2 million9.5 million36.84%

The founder keeps 3.5 million shares in every scenario:

  • Outside or investor purchase: 3.5 million ÷ 10 million = 35%.
  • Company repurchase: 3.5 million ÷ 9.5 million = approximately 36.84%.

The higher percentage after the company repurchase does not mean the founder received free value. The company has spent $2 million that is no longer available to operate the business.

The founder receives the same gross price in all three outcomes. The ROFR changes who buys and, in the company-repurchase scenario, whose cash pays for it.

There is also a less visible cost: an outside buyer may decline to spend time on diligence if an existing investor can take the deal afterward. A ROFR can therefore affect whether an offer arrives, even when its matching terms look fair.

What the agreement says

The National Venture Capital Association's model Right of First Refusal and Co-Sale Agreement separates three rights. In paraphrase:

  • The company has a right to purchase covered shares that a specified holder proposes to transfer.
  • Covered investors have a secondary refusal right over shares the company does not purchase.
  • Investors also receive a separate co-sale right that can let them participate as sellers.

That last right is not another purchase right. It lets an investor sell alongside the founder, subject to the agreement's mechanics.

The model also addresses notices, exercise procedures, permitted transfers and termination. Your signed version may differ substantially from the model.

For a Delaware corporation, Section 202 of the Delaware General Corporation Law addresses notice of transfer restrictions. A restriction generally must be conspicuously noted on the share certificate or included in the required notice for uncertificated shares. Without that notice, it is ineffective against a person without actual knowledge of it.

Delaware law also limits company repurchases. A contractual right to buy shares does not override those limits.

Before a secondary sale, gather the applicable agreements, amendments and prior waivers. A prospective buyer will need to understand the restrictions and see evidence that the required process has been completed.

What is normal, and what to question

The NVCA model's company-first, investor-second sequence is an established venture-financing structure. That does not make every provision in a proposed agreement acceptable.

Focus on these points:

Which transactions are covered?

Check whose shares are restricted and which transactions count as transfers. Gifts, transfers to trusts, pledges and indirect ownership changes may receive different treatment. An estate-planning exception may require the recipient to agree to the existing restrictions.

Question a provision that reaches beyond shareholder transfers to give a strategic investor a ROFR over an acquisition of the entire company. That is a broader restriction and can discourage potential acquirers.

Can the holder buy only part?

A right to purchase part of the offered block can leave the outside buyer with fewer shares than it wanted. The buyer might then walk away, leaving the founder with only a partial sale.

Check whether exercise must cover the whole block, whether investors can take unused allocations and what happens to the remainder. Do not assume the example above's all-or-nothing structure applies.

What counts as matching?

A cash offer is easier to match than an offer involving another company's stock, deferred payments or contingent consideration.

The agreement should explain how noncash consideration is valued and whether cash substitution is permitted. Otherwise, two parties may agree on the headline price but disagree about whether the offer was actually matched.

How long can the process take?

Count the entire sequence: initial notice, company response, investor response, any further allocation period and closing.

Question an open-ended process or a right that can be exercised without a clear purchase deadline. The outside buyer needs to know when the shares will actually be available.

When does the restriction end?

Look for express termination events and a clear waiver mechanism. A financing, acquisition or public offering does not erase every ROFR simply because the transaction is important.

Identify who can waive each right. Company approval alone may not waive investors' separate rights.

ROFR versus ROFO and other rights

The operative clause matters more than the label.

RightWhen it appliesWhat the holder gets
Right of first refusalAfter the owner has proposed terms with an outside buyerA chance to match those terms
Right of first offer (ROFO)Before the owner pursues an outside sale, as the contract specifiesA first opportunity to propose or negotiate a purchase
Co-sale or tag-along rightWhen another shareholder makes a covered saleA right to participate as a seller
Pro rata participation rightWhen the company issues covered new securitiesA right to invest to help maintain ownership

A ROFO does not ordinarily give its holder the same final matching opportunity as a ROFR. However, it may restrict a later outside sale, such as requiring another process if the owner accepts less favorable terms.

In startup documents, a ROFR over existing shares is also different from a right to participate in a new financing. A founder selling stock receives the proceeds personally; a company issuing new stock receives financing.

Questions founders ask

What is ROFR in simple terms?

It means "let me buy on those terms before you sell to someone else." The owner proposes a covered sale, and the right holder gets the contractual opportunity to take the buyer's place. The holder must follow the agreement's procedure, not just express interest.

Is right of first refusal good or bad?

It depends on your position. For the holder, it offers control over who becomes an owner without requiring an immediate purchase. For the seller, it adds delay and can reduce outside buyers' interest. For a startup, the benefit of controlling share transfers must be weighed against founder liquidity and transaction friction.

What is better, a ROFO or ROFR?

A ROFO often suits an owner who wants to approach the existing holder first, then pursue outside buyers without a final matching right hanging over the sale. A ROFR often suits a holder who wants to see a third party's price before deciding. Scope, deadlines and later-sale restrictions can matter more than the name.

What is the difference between ROFR and ROFO?

The main difference is timing. A ROFO gives the holder an opportunity before the outside-sale process specified in the contract. A ROFR lets the holder match an outside deal the owner proposes to accept. Neither label tells you the deadline, whether partial purchases are allowed or how noncash offers work.

Can I sell my startup shares after the ROFR holder passes?

Only if you satisfy the remaining requirements. You may still need investor responses, co-sale compliance, board consent and a valid securities-law basis for the sale. The agreement may also require closing within a particular window without changing the buyer or material terms.

Related terms

Sources

  1. National Venture Capital Association, Model Legal Documents, "Right of First Refusal and Co-Sale Agreement."
  2. Delaware General Assembly, Delaware Code, Title 8, Section 202, "Restrictions on transfer and ownership of securities."
  3. Delaware General Assembly, Delaware Code, Title 8, Section 160, corporate powers concerning ownership and repurchase of its own stock.