Secondary sale

Also called a secondary share sale.

Business basics4min read

A secondary sale transfers an existing investment from its current holder to a buyer, rather than creating a new investment through an issuer. In a startup share sale, the selling shareholder receives the proceeds, not the startup.

Key takeaways

  • A secondary sale gives an existing shareholder liquidity. It does not fund the company's operations.
  • A transfer between shareholders does not create new shares or dilute other holders.
  • Private-company shares often have transfer restrictions. Finding a buyer does not mean you are free to sell.
  • A fundraising round can combine primary capital for the company with secondary proceeds for existing shareholders.

How a secondary sale works

Stock-exchange trades are secondary transactions. At a private startup, a secondary sale usually requires a negotiated transaction rather than an exchange order. The seller might be a founder, employee, angel investor or venture fund.

The buyer and seller agree on the share class, quantity and price. They then address transfer restrictions, required notices and approvals before payment and an update to the company's stock ledger.

This page focuses on US practice. US securities laws restrict resales of private-company stock, and company approval alone does not provide a securities-law exemption. Counsel should confirm the route for the particular transaction.

Selling $2 million of founder shares

A startup has 10 million shares outstanding. Its founder owns 6 million, or 60%. At $4 per share, selling 500,000 founder shares produces $2 million.

Compare that with the company raising $2 million by issuing 500,000 new shares at the same price. No options, convertibles, fees or taxes are included.

OutcomeSecondary salePrimary sale
Shares sold500,000 existing founder shares500,000 newly issued shares
Total shares afterward10 million10.5 million
Founder shares afterward5.5 million6 million
Founder ownership afterward5.5M ÷ 10M = 55%6M ÷ 10.5M = 57.14%
Cash received by founder$2 million$0
Cash received by company$0$2 million

The secondary sale reduces only the seller's ownership. The primary sale dilutes every existing shareholder, but puts money into the business. A founder who needs personal liquidity and a company that needs operating cash have different problems to solve.

What the documents say

The NVCA model Right of First Refusal and Co-Sale Agreement sets out who can buy first when a covered stockholder proposes a transfer, and when eligible investors can participate as sellers.

Those rights are different:

  • A right of first refusal lets its holder buy the offered shares on the specified terms before the proposed buyer.
  • A co-sale right lets its holder sell alongside the original seller, subject to the agreement's conditions.

Check the actual agreement's notice periods, exceptions and allocation rules. Separate restrictions in bylaws or stock purchase agreements may also require approval.

Before closing, the buyer needs evidence of ownership, the share class and the approvals or waivers required for the transfer. Reconcile those documents with the stock ledger.

Terms to question before signing

Compare rights, not just prices. Common shares do not acquire a preferred investor's liquidation preference merely because they sell at the last round's price.

Also check:

  • Whether a buyer demands information or other rights beyond those attached to the shares.
  • Whether co-sale participation changes how many shares the founder can sell.
  • Who pays transaction expenses and what the seller receives after fees and taxes.

Questions founders ask

What does "secondary sale" mean?

It means an existing holder sells an investment they already own. For startup equity, the proceeds belong to that shareholder. A sale by an early investor is secondary even if the founder sells nothing.

What is primary vs secondary sale?

A primary sale involves newly issued securities and brings money to the issuer. A secondary sale involves existing securities and pays the seller. One financing can contain both, so separate the amounts when describing how much the company raised.

Is a secondary offering good or bad?

Neither automatically. A secondary sale exchanges future upside for cash now; investors will want to understand a founder's reason for selling. Public-market reporting sometimes uses "secondary offering" loosely for a follow-on offering, so check whether it includes newly issued shares and dilution.

What is the difference between a tender offer and a secondary sale?

A tender offer is a process for inviting shareholders to sell on stated terms, often by a deadline. It can produce secondary sales to an investor or repurchases by the company. A privately negotiated sale is not automatically a tender offer.

Related terms

Sources

  1. National Venture Capital Association, "Model Legal Documents," Right of First Refusal and Co-Sale Agreement.
  2. US Securities and Exchange Commission, "Rule 144: Selling Restricted and Control Securities."
  3. US Securities and Exchange Commission, Investor.gov, "Tender Offer."