Clawback

Also called recoupment or recovery.

Business basics4min read

A clawback is a right or requirement to recover money or benefits already paid or granted when a specified condition occurs. In business, it often applies to bonuses, stock awards or investment-fund profits that later prove excessive or no longer qualify.

Key takeaways

  • A payment can be valid when made and still become repayable later.
  • The trigger matters: an accounting correction, early departure and excess fund distributions are different cases.
  • A fund's carried-interest clawback targets its manager or carry recipients, not the startup it invested in.
  • A compensation clawback is different from a company's right to repurchase unvested founder shares.

How a clawback works

The contract or law establishes the trigger, calculation, person responsible and recovery process. Recovery might require cash repayment or permit an offset against future payments, subject to applicable law.

For employees, the trigger might be a financial restatement, misconduct or departure before a retention period ends. The agreement determines whether repayment covers the whole award or only part.

In private equity and venture capital, a general partner (GP) clawback returns excess carried interest. Early investment gains can produce carry payments that later losses make too large.

How a later loss creates a $2 million clawback

A fund invests $10 million in each of two companies. Its agreement allows deal-by-deal carry distributions at an illustrative 20% rate. Ignore fees, expenses, taxes and preferred returns.

InvestmentCapital investedExit proceedsProfit or loss
Company A$10M$30M$20M
Company B$10M$0-$10M
Total$20M$30M$10M

Company A exits first. The manager receives 20% × $20M = $4M in carry.

Company B later becomes worthless. Across the whole fund, profit is only $10M, so final carry entitlement is 20% × $10M = $2M.

The clawback is $4M already received − $2M actually owed = $2M returned to the fund for its investors. Company A does not owe that money merely because another investment failed.

What the documents say

ILPA's Model Limited Partnership Agreement (Deal-by-Deal Waterfall) includes a GP clawback to reconcile carry distributions with the fund's overall results. The signed limited partnership agreement controls the calculation, testing dates, repayment obligations and any limits.

For founders, read the actual stock or compensation agreement rather than relying on the label:

ProvisionWhat it does
ClawbackRecovers compensation or another benefit after a specified trigger
VestingDetermines when an award becomes earned or no longer subject to forfeiture or repurchase
Unvested-share repurchase rightLets the company buy back specified unvested shares under the agreement

A right to repurchase unvested founder shares does not, by itself, authorize taking back vested shares.

For fundraising diligence, share the stock purchase agreements, equity plan and any side letters affecting repayment or repurchase rights. A cap table alone does not show those terms.

What is established, and what to question

Under SEC Rule 10D-1 and exchange listing standards, most companies listed on US exchanges must recover excess incentive-based compensation from current or former executive officers after certain accounting restatements. The recovery period covers the three completed fiscal years immediately preceding the date the company is required to prepare the restatement. Misconduct is not required. That listing rule does not automatically apply to private startups.

For funds, ILPA Principles 3.0 recommends an all-capital-back waterfall to reduce clawback risk. This is investor guidance, not a universal legal requirement.

For a private-company agreement, question vague triggers, unlimited discretion and an undefined repayment calculation. Ask whether the clause recovers only an overpayment or also requires returning otherwise earned benefits. Do not accept "standard clawback" as a substitute for those answers.

Questions founders ask

What does "clawback" mean in simple terms?

It means taking back money or a benefit under a contract or legal rule after a specified event.

Can you give me an example of a clawback?

A hypothetical bonus is paid at $20,000 but later corrected to $15,000. If the applicable clawback covers only the excess, repayment is $20,000 − $15,000 = $5,000.

What is another term for clawback?

"Recoupment" and "recovery" are common alternatives. A document might call it a compensation recovery policy or repayment provision. Read the operative terms, not just the heading.

Are clawbacks illegal?

No. Some are required by law; others depend on an enforceable contract. Wage laws and other limits still apply, so a signed clause does not make every repayment demand lawful.

Related terms

Sources

  1. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, "Listing Standards for Recovery of Erroneously Awarded Compensation."
  2. Institutional Limited Partners Association, Model Limited Partnership Agreement (Deal-by-Deal Waterfall), 2020.
  3. Institutional Limited Partners Association, ILPA Principles 3.0, 2019.