Common stock vs. preferred stock

Deals and equity4min read

Common stock gives owners the residual claim on a company's value. Preferred stock gets priority for specified dividends or liquidation payouts, but remains behind creditors. Public-market preferred often emphasizes income; startup preferred usually emphasizes downside protection and conversion into common.

DifferenceCommon stockPreferred stock
Liquidation payoutsReceives what remains after creditors and preferred claimsReceives its contractual priority before common, but after creditors
DividendsPaid if declared; no standard fixed paymentOften has a stated dividend rate in public markets; startup terms vary
VotingOften carries voting rights, though nonvoting classes existPublic-market preferred often has limited votes; startup preferred often votes alongside common and has separate approval rights
UpsideParticipates in growth in the equity's valueDepends on the terms; convertible startup preferred can participate by converting into common
Typical startup holdersFounders and employees, directly or through exercised optionsVenture investors and some angel investors

Neither class guarantees a return. "Preferred" describes priority, not safety.

A $2M investment produces different payouts at a $5M sale

A startup raises $2 million at a $10 million post-money valuation. The investor owns 20% on an as-converted basis, and the founders retain 80%.

Compare two versions of that investment:

  • Common stock: the investor receives 20% of sale proceeds.
  • Preferred stock: the investor receives a 1x non-participating liquidation preference, with the option to convert into common.

The example excludes options, other investors and later dilution. Sale proceeds are the amount available to shareholders after debts and transaction costs.

Sale proceedsInvestor with commonFounders with common investorInvestor with preferredFounders with preferred investor
$5M$1M$4M$2M$3M
$20M$4M$16M$4M$16M

At the $5 million sale, common pays the investor $5M × 20% = $1M. Preferred instead pays the $2 million preference. The founders receive the remaining $3 million.

At the $20 million sale, the preferred investor converts: $20M × 20% = $4M, which beats the $2 million preference.

"Non-participating" matters. The investor chooses the preference or the common-stock payout, not both. Participating preferred can collect its preference and then share in the remaining proceeds, subject to any negotiated cap.

For founders, identical ownership percentages do not necessarily mean identical exit proceeds. The preference matters most when the sale price is low relative to the money raised.

When each fits

Common stock fits founders and employee ownership because it gives them the residual upside after senior claims. Employee stock options usually give the right to buy common stock, rather than preferred.

For a public-market investor, common stock fits an investment focused on business growth and potential price appreciation. Preferred can fit an income objective, but dividend suspension, interest-rate changes and issuer redemption terms still matter. It is not a substitute for an insured deposit.

Startup preferred serves a different purpose: investors put substantial cash into a risky company and negotiate priority, conversion rights and approval rights in return. It is not necessarily an income investment, and the company need not pay regular cash dividends.

What the documents say

For a Delaware corporation, inspect the certificate of incorporation, including amendments and any preferred-stock designations. Section 151 of the Delaware General Corporation Law permits classes with different dividend, liquidation and conversion rights.

The NVCA model Term Sheet presents alternative liquidation structures, including non-participating and participating preferred. Its model Certificate of Incorporation also addresses deemed liquidation events: specified acquisitions can trigger the preference even though the company is being sold rather than shut down.

The term sheet summarizes the proposed economics. The definitive charter and agreements establish the rights. Information rights, board arrangements and other protections also appear in separate financing agreements.

Investors reviewing a financing need the current charter, cap table and relevant agreements together. A cap table shows ownership, but not the full payout order or approval rights.

Terms worth questioning

Question provisions that let investors collect their preference and then share in the remainder, accumulate unpaid dividends into a larger claim, or demand repayment through redemption rights. These provisions can change founder proceeds or create cash pressure without changing the headline ownership percentage.

Separate protective provisions from economic rights. An investor's veto over a sale or new financing can matter even when that investor owns a minority stake.

Questions people ask

Does preferred stock always pay dividends?

No. Public-company preferred often has a stated dividend, but payment is not guaranteed. Startup preferred need not pay regular cash dividends. Check whether dividends are cumulative, whether they require declaration and whether unpaid amounts increase an exit payout.

Does preferred stock mean an investor controls the company?

No. Control depends on voting power, board composition and separate approval rights. A minority preferred investor might lack control over ordinary operations but still be able to block a sale or financing.

Is the preferred share price the value of employee common stock?

Not automatically. Preferred and common have different rights, so the latest preferred financing price is not a direct valuation of employee common stock. An option's exercise price also does not guarantee what the employee could sell the resulting shares for.

Related terms

Sources

  1. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Investor.gov, "Stocks."
  2. National Venture Capital Association, "Model Legal Documents," including the Term Sheet and Certificate of Incorporation.
  3. Delaware General Assembly, Delaware General Corporation Law, Title 8, Section 151.