Equity sharing

Deals and equity4min read

Equity sharing is an informal phrase with no single legal definition. In business, it means giving someone company ownership or a right tied to its value. In real estate, it means sharing a property's equity or appreciation.

Employees may receive equity for work, co-founders split ownership when starting a business, and investors buy equity for cash. The actual arrangement matters more than the label: a stock grant, stock option and cash bonus tied to company value create different rights.

Key takeaways

  • Actual shares provide ownership. Options provide a right to buy shares; phantom equity provides a contractual payout without ownership.
  • A percentage needs a denominator. "10% of outstanding shares" can mean less than "10% on a fully diluted basis."
  • New shares dilute existing holders unless they also buy enough shares to maintain their percentage.
  • Ownership percentage does not, by itself, determine voting control or the share of sale proceeds.

How equity sharing works

For a startup, equity sharing usually takes one of these forms:

  • Co-founder stock: founders purchase shares, often subject to vesting and a company repurchase right.
  • Employee awards: restricted stock, options or other awards compensate people for their work.
  • Investor equity: investors buy shares, often preferred stock with rights that common shareholders do not have.
  • Phantom equity: a contract promises compensation tied to company value without issuing shares.

The agreement should identify the instrument, number of shares or units, price, vesting conditions and what happens when someone leaves. "We'll give you 5% equity" leaves too much unresolved.

How a $2 million investment changes the founders' ownership

A startup raises $2 million at an $8 million pre-money valuation. Its pre-round capitalization includes two founders and an unissued employee option pool.

The example uses fully diluted ownership, with the entire pool counted before the investment. There are no SAFEs, convertible notes or pool increases.

Holder or reserveBefore investmentAfter investment
Founder A60%48%
Founder B30%24%
Unissued option pool10%8%
New investor0%20%
Total100%100%

Post-money valuation = $8 million + $2 million = $10 million.

Investor ownership = $2 million ÷ $10 million = 20%.

Existing percentages are multiplied by 80%. Founder A therefore holds 60% × 80% = 48%.

Neither founder sold shares or received the investment personally. The company received the cash and issued new shares. The option pool is a reserve, not a shareholder.

Founder A's 48% also does not guarantee 48% of an acquisition price. Debt, transaction costs and preferred-stock rights can change the payout.

What the documents say

There is no standard "equity sharing agreement" for every business situation.

The NVCA model Stock Purchase Agreement identifies the preferred shares investors purchase and their purchase price. Its model Certificate of Incorporation sets out rights attached to those shares, including liquidation preferences.

For founder and employee equity, the relevant stock purchase or award agreement addresses vesting, departure and repurchase provisions. An equity plan may supply additional rules.

A fundraising cap table should reconcile with the signed agreements before investors receive it. A spreadsheet percentage cannot replace the underlying rights.

What's normal, and what to question

YC's "How to Split Equity Among Co-Founders" describes four-year vesting with a one-year cliff as typical in Silicon Valley. That is a reference point, not a legal requirement.

Question an offer that leaves any of these unanswered:

  • Percentage of what? Ask whether the calculation includes options, the unissued pool and convertible securities.
  • At what date? A percentage before financing differs from the same percentage after financing.
  • What happens on departure? Check forfeiture, repurchase and option exercise provisions.
  • Which rights attach? Economic ownership, voting rights and board control are separate questions.

Equity sharing versus profit sharing

ArrangementWhat the recipient receivesOwnership required?
Equity sharingShares or a contractual right tied to company valueDepends on the instrument
Profit sharingA share of profit as defined in the agreementNo
Revenue sharingA share of defined revenueNo

A profitable business can pay profit-sharing bonuses without giving employees stock. A startup can grant stock while paying no dividends and generating no profit.

Questions founders ask

Does equity sharing mean giving up control?

Not necessarily. Control depends on voting rights, board composition and investor consent rights, not just ownership percentage. A founder with more than half the shares can still need investor approval for specified decisions.

Can I take back equity when someone leaves?

Only if the documents provide that right. Unvested founder stock may be subject to repurchase, and unvested employee awards often lapse. Vested shares do not automatically return to the company because employment ends.

Can equity create tax before someone receives cash?

Yes. Under US rules, receiving shares, vesting or exercising an option can create tax before a sale. The timing depends on the award and any applicable tax elections, so review the tax treatment before issuing or accepting it.

Related terms

Sources

  1. National Venture Capital Association, "Model Legal Documents": Stock Purchase Agreement and Certificate of Incorporation.
  2. Y Combinator, Michael Seibel, "How to Split Equity Among Co-Founders," 2015.
  3. Internal Revenue Service, Publication 525, "Taxable and Nontaxable Income."