Out-of-the-money option
Also called an OTM option. Employee stock options in this position are also called underwater options.
An out-of-the-money (OTM) option has no intrinsic value. A call is OTM when its exercise price exceeds the underlying asset's market price; a put is OTM when its exercise price is below that market price.
"Option exercise price" is not a synonym. The exercise price, also called the strike price, is the price specified in the option contract.
Key takeaways
- OTM does not necessarily mean worthless. Before expiration, a listed option can still have a positive trading price.
- Employee stock options are calls: they become underwater when the common shares are worth less than the exercise price.
- A startup's preferred-share financing price is not automatically the value of its common shares.
- A falling share price does not itself reset the strike or cancel outstanding options.
How it works
An option gives its holder a right, not an obligation, to buy or sell an underlying asset at a specified price.
For a call, immediate exercise only creates positive intrinsic value when the shares are worth more than the exercise price:
Call intrinsic value per share = greater of $0 or (share price − exercise price).
A put works in reverse: its intrinsic value is the greater of $0 or (exercise price − share price).
Neither formula includes the premium paid to buy the option. A purchased option can be in the money and still produce a loss after that cost.
For private-company employee options, there may be no quoted market price. Use a supportable current value for the underlying common shares, and remember that a valuation is not an offer to buy them.
A $5 strike across three share values
An employee holds 10,000 vested options with a $5 exercise price. Exercising all of them would cost:
10,000 × $5 = $50,000
The table uses hypothetical common-share values and ignores taxes and fees.
| Common-share value | Value of 10,000 shares | Exercise cost | Total intrinsic value | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $3 | $30,000 | $50,000 | $0 | Out of the money |
| $5 | $50,000 | $50,000 | $0 | At the money |
| $8 | $80,000 | $50,000 | $30,000 | In the money |
At $8, intrinsic value is 10,000 × ($8 − $5) = $30,000.
At $3, it is zero, not negative $20,000: the employee can choose not to exercise. But if the shares remain below $5 through expiration, the options provide no positive exercise payoff.
Even the $30,000 figure is not necessarily available cash. Private-company shares may have no buyer.
What the documents say
The Options Clearing Corporation's Characteristics and Risks of Standardized Options distinguishes intrinsic value from time value. An option's premium can exceed its immediate exercise value because time remains for a favorable price move. That is why an OTM listed option can trade above $0.
An employee option agreement serves a different purpose. Read its exercise price, share count, expiration date and post-termination exercise provisions. These determine what the employee can buy and when. They do not guarantee the shares' current value or a future sale.
What founders should question
An underwater grant is not proof that its original exercise price was wrong. The company's value could have fallen since the grant.
Question a compensation calculation that uses the latest preferred-share price without accounting for different share rights. Also question a cap table that drops underwater grants merely because they have no current intrinsic value: outstanding options remain outstanding until exercised, expired or otherwise terminated.
For retention, distinguish the grant's original promise from its current incentive value. More options at an underwater strike do not provide the same economics as the same number at a lower strike.
Out of the money versus in the money
| Status | Call option | Put option |
|---|---|---|
| Out of the money | Share price below strike | Share price above strike |
| At the money | Share price equals strike | Share price equals strike |
| In the money | Share price above strike | Share price below strike |
These labels describe exercise value, not the holder's total profit.
Questions founders ask
What is an out-of-the-money stock option?
It is a stock option with no current intrinsic value. For an employee option, the exercise price is above the current value of the common shares. The employee has a right to buy, not an obligation.
Are ITM or OTM calls better?
Neither is automatically better. Compare the premium, expiration and price move needed to break even. For a purchased call held to expiration, the break-even share price is the strike plus the premium per share, before fees. A lower premium does not necessarily mean lower risk.
What is OTM trading?
It means buying or selling options that are currently out of the money. It is not a separate market or a single strategy. Buying an OTM option and selling one create different risks.
