Stock appreciation right (SAR)
Also called a share appreciation right.
A stock appreciation right (SAR) is a compensation award that pays the increase in a company's share value above a set base price, in cash or shares. Unlike a stock option, it does not require the holder to pay an exercise price.
Key takeaways
- The gross payout is the number of SARs exercised multiplied by the increase above the base price.
- Cash-settled SARs do not give the recipient ownership. Share-settled SARs can dilute existing shareholders.
- Vesting and payment are different events. The plan controls when rights become exercisable and when payment occurs.
- For US employees, the payout is ordinarily compensation income, not a capital gain.
How SARs work
A company grants a specified number of rights with a base price, a vesting schedule and an expiration date. Each right tracks the appreciation on one share unless the agreement specifies otherwise.
If the share value rises above the base price, an exercised SAR pays the difference. If it does not rise, there is no appreciation to collect.
The recipient does not buy the underlying shares at the base price. That price is a measuring point, not a bill. Tax withholding can still reduce the cash or shares received.
For private companies, the valuation method matters: there is no public market price to look up.
A rise from $2 to $8 creates a $60,000 award
An employee holds 10,000 fully vested SARs with a $2 base price. The employee exercises and receives payment when the applicable share value is $8. There is no payout cap; taxes and withholding are excluded.
| Calculation | Result |
|---|---|
| Appreciation per right: $8 − $2 | $6 |
| Gross award value: 10,000 × $6 | $60,000 |
| Cash settlement | $60,000 |
| Share settlement: $60,000 ÷ $8 | 7,500 shares |
The employee does not pay the $20,000 that exercising 10,000 options at a $2 strike price would require.
For the founder, settlement changes the cost. A $60,000 cash payout consumes two months of cash at a $30,000 monthly burn rate, with other spending unchanged. Issuing 7,500 shares preserves that cash but dilutes existing owners. The agreement determines which settlement applies.
The relevant value is the value specified for the underlying shares, not automatically the preferred-share price from the latest funding round.
What the documents say
The plan and grant agreement should identify the base price, underlying shares, vesting, exercise deadline, valuation method and form of settlement. Check what happens after resignation, termination or an acquisition.
US Treasury Regulation §1.409A-1(b)(5)(i)(B) sets conditions for SARs to qualify for an exemption from Section 409A's deferred-compensation rules. Among them, the exercise price cannot be below the underlying stock's grant-date fair market value, and the award cannot include an additional compensation-deferral feature. Other conditions apply.
That exemption matters: a discounted or improperly structured award can trigger Section 409A tax consequences. Calling an award a "SAR" does not establish its tax treatment.
Terms to question before signing
Question an unexplained valuation, unclear payment timing or language that leaves cash-versus-share settlement uncertain. For a private company, ask whether a payout could become due before an exit and where the cash would come from.
For fundraising diligence, include the plan, grant agreements and outstanding award schedule. Investors need to see potential dilution and cash-settlement obligations, even when recipients are not yet shareholders.
SARs versus stock options
| Feature | Stock appreciation right | Stock option |
|---|---|---|
| Economic benefit | Increase above the base price | Right to buy shares at the strike price |
| Exercise-price payment | None | Required, though cashless exercise may be available |
| Settlement | Cash or shares, under the agreement | Shares upon exercise |
| Ownership | Only if shares are delivered | When shares are acquired |
A SAR is not necessarily phantom stock. Phantom-stock plans can pay the full value of a notional share; a SAR pays only appreciation above its base price.
Questions founders ask
How does a stock appreciation right work?
The award tracks share-price growth above a base price. Vesting earns the right under the plan, but payment follows its exercise and settlement rules. Check the expiration date and any shorter exercise window after employment ends.
What is a stock appreciation right scheme?
It means a company's SAR compensation program. "Scheme" is common terminology outside the US; US documents usually call it a plan. The plan provides the overall rules, while individual grant agreements specify each recipient's award.
How are SARs taxed in the US?
For an employee's qualifying SAR exercised and paid immediately, the payout is ordinarily wage income subject to withholding. Receiving shares instead of cash does not make that initial compensation a capital gain. Later changes in the shares' value can produce capital gains or losses when sold.
